Sometimes when I open a bag of dog treats, they make me gag. These made me do a double take FOR REAL!! They smell sooo good!! I know they are human grade but I didn’t expect them to smell exactly like peanut butter cookies! They are perfectly soft so they can easily be broken into smaller pieces for small dogs (see pictures). My granddog LOVES them!!!

As soon as I opened the bag the dogs knew what was in it was good. My Aussie is not even a big PB fan and loves them. Nice size. Not to big and not to small. A large amount of treats in the bag. And they loved them. I even tried a bite. Not bad at all. Will be buying more

Sam’s Club dog treats are a tasty, affordable option for pet owners. My dog gets excited when he hears the bag and love them during training or as rewards. With convenient delivery and great quality, these treats offer excellent value. I highly recommend them for happy, healthy pups.

They don't smell bad to me, but my dog who normally eats pretty much any treat won't touch them! Like she actually turns her head away from them as if in disgust. I trust my dog's instincts. Who knows what goes on in "Walmart world" to keep prices lower. I will see if I can return them.

Our four Newfoundlands go absolutely stupid for these. All four are picky in different ways, so the fact they are loved by all is still geeking us out. From just “nigh night” cookies to helping to train the puppy, these are working. We just randomly grabbed them thinking we would give them a shot. Now they are part of our permanent arsenal! They are not huge, no where near the size of the milk bone treats, but they work and are perfect for a light snack. HA! For smaller dogs, these might be big. For training purposes, I rip them in quarters or half.

my dog seemed to like them well enough, but I just can't get over the fact that they smell like wet paint. I have not noticed mold on any of mine (yet), but am keeping a watch for it as per some other reviews have mentioned. most likely won't be purchasing again.

I have two English bulldogs the are very picky and they love them

Soft and my dog loves them

Everything that I've purchased in the store my husband and I really have liked.

My Dog loves these and they are pretty healthy