These smell terrible to me but my dogs love them! They smell like artificial banana smell. I figured there was no way my dogs were going to eat these, but they really love them. The bag is large and there are lots of treats in it. The treats are also large. If you wanted, you could break them in half as they are soft. I will definitely buy these again.

I have 2 small dogs and they both love these treats. I have given them things with peanut butter before which they love but the addition of banana makes them even better. These will last a long time because they are large enough to give them smaller pieces.

These dog treats look like little cookies. They are firm enough not to fall apart, but not too hard for discriminating chewers. The ingredient list looks like any store bought cookie would. There is no noticeable smell like some dog treats have. Both of my dogs eat them up and come back for more.

My dog absolutely loves these treats. If she hears the crinkle of the bag, she comes running. The treats are the perfect size and the paw print shape is cute. The treats have a pretty strong smell of banana and peanut butter. I love the clean and limited ingredient list. I highly recommend these dog treats!

I have a 12 year old black lab and recently acquired a 8 week old black lab puppy. I thought I would use these treats as incentives during my training routines. This worked like a charm. Both dogs loved them and were very attentive during training. I especially like how they held togeter in by pouch.

These pup treats get an A for taste and cuteness. My dog loves them and they are shaped like cute little dog paws. I like that they have natural flavors and they are simple minimal ingredients. They are soft which I prefer in a dog treat. They actually smell like peanut butter, yum. I only have 2 recommendations for how they could improve. I wish they would lose the sunflower oil for a healthier option like coconut oil and they could be a little smaller. Although that isn’t a huge deal because they do break easily. I use a lot of treats and it would be convenient to have them be smaller.

My dog was too picky for this because it’s like a human cookie. Its ingredients are just peanut butter and banana and oat. My dog wasn’t attracted to that and it smells and feels like a toddler cookie. The texture is nice, the cookie is nice. I tried it and found it was good. They give you so many and it’s well worth the price. Wish my dog would eat them but I thought they were good.

These Member's Mark Peanut Butter and Banana flavored Dog Treats were absolutely loved by my two dogs. Even though the treats are a larger in size and my dogs are small (15lbs) they were able to eat these treats with no problem. The treats are soft and chewy as the name indicates and make it easy for the dog to enjoy.

These are a big hit with our fur baby. They honestly smell like human food. The peanut and banana are very much loved by him. Cute little paw print design. resealable back keeps them fresh. And the ingredients are all natural. Pup tested, Mom approved

These peanut butter and banana soft chew cookies were a big hit at the house. We had three dogs try them out over the week and they all loved them. They crumbled them up to get every morsel out of each cookie and didn't like sharing! I even tried one to test out the human grade aspect and they tasted like bananas and peanut butter, but not as sweet for these pups which is good! I really like the idea and the actual product! The sized bag is great as it will go a long way too.