As soon as I opened the bag the dogs knew what was in it was good. My Aussie is not even a big PB fan and loves them. Nice size. Not to big and not to small. A large amount of treats in the bag. And they loved them. I even tried a bite. Not bad at all. Will be buying more

Sam’s Club dog treats are a tasty, affordable option for pet owners. My dog gets excited when he hears the bag and love them during training or as rewards. With convenient delivery and great quality, these treats offer excellent value. I highly recommend them for happy, healthy pups.

My doggies love these! I love how they are super soft and not so hard on their teeth. I have three older Great Danes and finding treats that aren’t hard on their stomach or hard to chew is a challenge. These are great for them and they smell amazing.

So, Member's Mark Peanut Butter and Banana Dog Treats are dog approved. I have 3 dogs and 2 of them are known to eat anything and the last one is so picky. But even he liked the doggie treats which is very rare for him, and I am so glad he does like them. Because he is senior dog and needs to put on more weight so, I am very grateful for these treats because they will help me do that.

I have 2 small dogs and they both love these treats. I have given them things with peanut butter before which they love but the addition of banana makes them even better. These will last a long time because they are large enough to give them smaller pieces.

My pugs didnt really care for them but our pittie mix loved them and would do any trick you asked just to get another. Very strong peanut butter and banana smell and seems to be pretty healthy. Not many ingredients and you can pronounce each of them. I hope sams keeps them in stock.

We bought these for our grand dogs AND neighborhood dogs. We have found that at first the dogs are iffy about taking the treat but once they actually eat one they want more and more. Even a few day later when passing by our house they want more. They LOVE these awesome treats!!

The dogs absolutely love this and a beautiful presentation of the paw was a really great size, and the ingredients are beyond amazing, I cannot believe how many healthy and natural ingredients or in this. I can feel good about feeding this to my dogs. I absolutely love the size of the bag and how many are in there in the size of the tree, they were crunchy enough, but not too hard. And the dogs went crazy for them. They absolutely loved the tastes.A dog absolutely love this and a beautiful presentation of the paw was a really great size and the ingredients are beyond amazing.I cannot believe how many healthy and natural ingredients or in this?I can feel good about feeding this to my dogs.I absolutely love the size of the bag and how many are in there in the size of the tree?They were crunchy enough, but not too hard.And the dogs went crazy for them.They absolutely love the taste

I am so impressed with the quality of the Member's Mark Peanut Butter & Banana Soft & Chewy Dog Treats! Wow! I was thinking they would be good because they're made with human grade peanut butter and bananas. I was right. They are chewy and smell like actual food. My dog gets so happy for one of them. The bag is large ( 48 ounces ) and reseals with the press together function at the top. The paw print shape is cute too. I am very happy with these awesome treats.

These dog treats look like little cookies. They are firm enough not to fall apart, but not too hard for discriminating chewers. The ingredient list looks like any store bought cookie would. There is no noticeable smell like some dog treats have. Both of my dogs eat them up and come back for more.