Not soft and chewy. Have three dogs and none of them like these treats.

These looked very good but my puppy didn’t like them . He just smelled them and wouldn’t even try. He is very picky. I gave then to my granddaughter for her dog .

My dog is obsessed!!! She has learned to roll over, lay down and come inside ALL FOR THESE TREATS!!! She will roll over BEFORE we even present her with the treat!! I'm not kidding, these treats must have a special sauce!!

My Dogs love these and they stay together in the Dog cookie jar. They smell very aromatic and I use them for "find it" games to keep them engaged.

These are my favorite dog treats because I can leave them whole or easily break them apart for weight control and training. They have stayed soft in the treat jar. My 3 labs gobble them up.

Smell good, they are soft but firm so good for young and old. Large sized bag for a great price! Already ordered 2 more in case Sam's stops carrying them!

Thinking the peanut butter cookie would be a huge bit, I was so wrong. Most would not even eat it, or they took it and dropped it, leaving it for the one dog to snag it. Smells like peanut butter. Crumbly

My dog loved this treat! She is not a big fan of peanut butter so I was worried she wouldn't like them, but she did! These were great as a treat when she comes back in from going outside to use the bathroom!

Always hungry black lab loves these...can't give her too many but there's no hesitation when I offer them up....she gobbles em right down and waits for another.

My pup LOVES these soft cookies. They smell good enough to make me want to eat them. When my pup sees the package he immediately sits and gives me "the look". He then eats it very slowly to savor the goodness. (he is a lab mix) Only problem is that I can't find them anymore.