My dog absolutely loves these treat and I don’t blame her. They smell delicious and have a soft texture. It wouldn’t be hard to mistake these for human treats. I’m not only impressed with how much she likes them, the smell, the calorie count, but also how well the bag stays sealed. These are also “safe” to put in your pocket as they don’t leave a residue either.

Sometimes when I open a bag of dog treats, they make me gag. These made me do a double take FOR REAL!! They smell sooo good!! I know they are human grade but I didn’t expect them to smell exactly like peanut butter cookies! They are perfectly soft so they can easily be broken into smaller pieces for small dogs (see pictures). My granddog LOVES them!!!

These treats are great. The package is huge first of all. 48oz huge! I got the peanut butter and banana soft chewy treats. The treats are paw shaped. Adorable! And they smell great! You can smell the banana and peanut butter. Our dog Rosie loved them!! And I love that they are made in the USA!

Norman and Miss Lola Fandango are absolutely in love with their new Member’s Mark Peanut Butter and Banana Dog Treats. Being Shihtzu’s, we always buy small treats because of their small mouth and teeth. These paw shaped treats were so soft and I was able to break them into pieces for them. The treats smelled so delicious I was tempted to try one myself. Treats are definitely worth a 5 paws up.

My doggies loved these treats! They go crazy for seconds! The treats are soft, chewy and they smell like peanut butter. I have 2 small dogs and I like that the treat is big enough that I can cut it in half. Happy to have found a dog treat that they really like.

The grand-pups loved these treats! They were drooling after the first bite, begging for more! The treats have all simple, natural ingredients in a very big bag! The individual treats are big in size as well, you can break them in half for small to medium size dogs. In the picture i placed a lime next to the treat to show the size.

These smell and look good enough to eat myself. My dogs both LOVE them. Nice big package, clean ingredients. Beautifully soft cookie type treats. Even my 16 year old geriatric doxie with no teeth loves them, although she does need me to break them up for her since she can’t bite through them. Overall these are fantastic, and I’ll definitely buy more when these run out.

These treats are a nice welcome to our home. They are made from REAL ingredients (only 11). That's saying a lot these days. I love that I can give our dog a healthier treat option and, BONUS, they don't stink! They actually smell like peanut butter. It is a real food, pet friendly treat. Our dog was so excited to have them when I opened the bag. Especially if you aren't a pet owner that feeds your dog scraps from the table, this gives your dog a "real food" soft & chewy treat to enjoy. The cute paw shape is an added cute factor for the treat giver. The bag is quite large, 3 pounds, and the bag shows that it contains over 85 treats. This bag will last a while! Also, they are made in the USA!

These Member's Mark Peanut Butter and Banana flavored Dog Treats were absolutely loved by my two dogs. Even though the treats are a larger in size and my dogs are small (15lbs) they were able to eat these treats with no problem. The treats are soft and chewy as the name indicates and make it easy for the dog to enjoy.

My dog said they taste great!