The last couple of times I purchased Stewart's extremely overpriced liver treats, the containers were full of dust and crumbs. I worried that these might be the same, being that they are in a bag, but they hold up extremely well. They're fairly consistent in size and have minimal breakage or dust, which I just use to sprinkle on the dog's food. I really hope Sam's doesn't quit selling these.

I like these because it is ONE ingredient and better for my dog than milk bone type treats. I came to order them again, but, they are out of stock!!! Please get these in asap! My dog just ran out of these!!! I would definitely recommend these for your dog or cat..

I have been buying these for a month now and my dogs only want these snacks and no others! They love them! and Im happy its only one ingredient, liver and no preservatives or bad stuff. I feel good feeding these to my 7 dogs. I just hope Sam's Club carries these as a permanent item and not discontinue it.

My dogs go crazy for these treats. Cant find in sams or online anywhere.

My dog loves this!!! I use it as a topper to her dog food and she licks the bowl clean every time!! Fantastic stuff!!

My dogs I love them and the bag is packed! Also, organs are so good for them. Not sure how much nutritional value is lost during the freeze dry process, but I know theyre not bad for them!

I don’t trust that these are what they claim to be (only freeze dried beef liver)… they look like wood chips, don’t have an scent, and none of my 16 cats (nor the neighbor’s cat) would eat them.

These are an awesome value. Our dogs go crazy for it! I grind some and use as a topper for their food sometimes. Outside warehouse it is a lot more expensive. Please keep stocking this item!

Great option for training, both kitties and doggies love them (more the dogs, lol!). They are crunchy and can easily be broken to offer smaller pieces. They do not cause an upset stomach or a gassy pet. Reasonable priced too!

I bought these to try and my dogs loved them. I went back for more and haven’t seen them since! Just like the real chicken jerky at Sam’s. Dogs loved it but now Sam’s has not had it for months!