My cats and stry cats won't eat it at all!! Did I buy a bad one?? Maybe I should go buy a coffee grinder & try to grind them up and sprinkle over their food?? I tried to break them into small pieces, but some were so hard to break down. I even tried with water like it said in the feeding direction, but nope, I left it out to see if others would eat it, but only a few pieces were gone.

Absolutely loved these treats. However every Sam's I checked does not have them in stock. It's mind-boggling when something gets great reviews how they quit carrying it. I tried calling and waited for customer service to pick up for 32 minutes then hung up. Sam's, get it together!!!!!!!

My dog loves this stuff. The only way to guarantee that she eats her food is to cut up a couple of the pieces and add it to her food. Sometimes she doesn't feel like eating, which is okay if it's only a day. But she tends to make not eating a habit. Prior to finding this, we had to resort to using Entyce medicine to get her to eat. This is far healthier than Entyce and much cheaper as well. I just wish it was still in our store. Since we weren't sure if it was just leaving our store or the entire system, we bought a almost a years worth of the bags. Just in case.

I like these because it is ONE ingredient and better for my dog than milk bone type treats. I came to order them again, but, they are out of stock!!! Please get these in asap! My dog just ran out of these!!! I would definitely recommend these for your dog or cat..

My dog absolutely loves these. It was the only treat she would eat when training her as a puppy so we have gone through quite a few bags. The price is great for the size of the bag and you get decent size pieces. The larger pieces are great for kongs because it takes a while for her to get it out. Keep these in stock!

My dogs absolutely loved these treats!! I wish that my Sam's Club store still sold them. I keep checking back to see if they get them in stock. I would even order to have them shipped if they were available. Fantastic quality and the dogs were so happy, which makes us happy.

I have bought at least 5 bags on these, they are very healthy for the dogs. Now, I only buy freeze dry treats for my dogs. I bought some chicken, salmon, and other kinds from different places, but I would like to see Sam's start carry more freeze dry treats.

My dogs love these Beef Liver treats I break them into small pieces and put on top of their Blue Buffalo dog food and they come running even my cat loves them. I normally will cook chicken liver fresh once a month so with freezed dried ones I don't have to.

All I have to do is pick-up the bag and my dogs and cats come running. The cats reach as far up my leg as they can and start eating these right out of my fingers. Please restock this item and make it a regular item on your shelves. My pets only have a few left and it's going to take some research to find a suitable replacement.

I make half of my large hound's food using bone broth, whatever meat is on sale, veggies and sometimes whole grains. I try to include stuff like giblets and liver but often those are out of stock at the local grocery store. I keep these treats aside for when I wasn't able to find liver. My dog has a mild beef, lamb and venison allergy, which causes her to develop red, inflamed skin, stinky ears and itching... probably other inflammation symptoms like achy joints too. Would much prefer these in chicken or other foul but as long as this is her only source of beef, given in moderation, she's not reacting with her usual allergy symptoms. She and all the other dogs in the neighborhood think these are the best treats ever.