I had no idea how these would be received. Treats were purchased before a 4 day work trip. I don't know if it was the liver treats, but they were on the best behavior for my mom and noticeably better behaved when I returned home. Also purchased the milk bone soft treats, they are way more animated for the liver treats. I am happy they are happy. Definitely purchasing again! (Breeds - Pitbull, Chihuahua, Min Pin, & Havanese)

I like these because it is ONE ingredient and better for my dog than milk bone type treats. I came to order them again, but, they are out of stock!!! Please get these in asap! My dog just ran out of these!!! I would definitely recommend these for your dog or cat..

My dogs absolutely loved these treats!! I wish that my Sam's Club store still sold them. I keep checking back to see if they get them in stock. I would even order to have them shipped if they were available. Fantastic quality and the dogs were so happy, which makes us happy.

Saw in these in store and there were such a deal, I thought I'd give them a try. The freeze-dried treats I normally buy are like $2.50/oz, so $0.76/oz was a total steal. These liver snacks are bigger chunks than I'm used to, but easy enough to break up into smaller bits for training. My Aussies really love these. I sometimes grind up a chunk and sprinkle it over their food. The treats are out of stock right now, but I (my dogs) really hope they are available again soon!

My cats and stry cats won't eat it at all!! Did I buy a bad one?? Maybe I should go buy a coffee grinder & try to grind them up and sprinkle over their food?? I tried to break them into small pieces, but some were so hard to break down. I even tried with water like it said in the feeding direction, but nope, I left it out to see if others would eat it, but only a few pieces were gone.

Our 75lb German Shep mix loves these; I add a little into the kibble with a dash of water to reconstitute/bring out the flavor and mix them around with the kibble. She cleans the food bowl completely when I add this. Good for puzzle toys/Kong treat use too, though I just use it in her food bowl. I do notice these tend to make our dog a bit gassy, so don't overdo these 'treats'...a little goes a long way in the kibble if you break them up. This is a very good value for the size bag you get.

Absolutely loved these treats. However every Sam's I checked does not have them in stock. It's mind-boggling when something gets great reviews how they quit carrying it. I tried calling and waited for customer service to pick up for 32 minutes then hung up. Sam's, get it together!!!!!!!

My dog absolutely loves these. It was the only treat she would eat when training her as a puppy so we have gone through quite a few bags. The price is great for the size of the bag and you get decent size pieces. The larger pieces are great for kongs because it takes a while for her to get it out. Keep these in stock!

All I have to do is pick-up the bag and my dogs and cats come running. The cats reach as far up my leg as they can and start eating these right out of my fingers. Please restock this item and make it a regular item on your shelves. My pets only have a few left and it's going to take some research to find a suitable replacement.

The last couple of times I purchased Stewart's extremely overpriced liver treats, the containers were full of dust and crumbs. I worried that these might be the same, being that they are in a bag, but they hold up extremely well. They're fairly consistent in size and have minimal breakage or dust, which I just use to sprinkle on the dog's food. I really hope Sam's doesn't quit selling these.