Initially my dogs gobbled it down then would not eat and just looked at me wanting their old food. The kibbles are smaller and all same shape size and color. I will not be buying and will stick to what I know my dogs like and do well eating.

Half way through this bag, I discovered mold. The food is in the bag in a plastic dog food bin (from Sams's) so it was in a dry environment. Will never purchase this again.

Smells terrible and made my dog so sick. He usually does fine with the members mark food. Decided to try this one and he was sick for days vomiting and upset stomach.

Food itself is good quality and my dogs eat it but Members Mark brand is never in stock anymore. I'm tired of changing the recipe but one is not in stock. Changing to something that is more reliable.

This product used to be good. Then it went out of stock when it came back in Stock. This bag was much much smaller so to get the same amount of food you need to buy more which comes out to be extremely expensive. We have bought this product for years and years and now we have to switch.......

My dogs ate every bit of it they loved it and I liked that chicken is the main ingredient and it’s grain free love that it has ingredients that will help their joint and bone health and I know their tummies will love the veggies for their digestive health

My dog is a picky eater. He was able to switch to this food without any negative reactions from his digestive system and loves it. It’s not appealing to my eyesight as it’s all a dark brown bits, but he prefers smaller bite size food and this is that!

My very picky Chow Lab mix loved this food. She normally hides food she doesn't like, but she took to this very well, and gobbled it right up. The transition was extremely easy, and she had no abdominal issues at all. She really enjoys this food, but I wish it was in bigger bags, and a bit cheaper. I normally buy her food in 50 pound bags, so I don't have to shop as often.

My dog is a picky eater. He loved this food, but it gave him intermittent diarrhea. He was on it for 8 months; then, the recall happened. We were forced to switch to another. It started to show up back on the shelves towards the end of February. Remembering that he loved this food, I bought two bags. I slowly introduced him back to this food. On day 2, he started to get diarrhea again. I'm definitely going to return both bags and switch back to the other brand.

I got the product to see how my 11 yr old shepherd would like it. The transition was a little difficult but ultimately I got her completely transitioned. However, she doesn't always empty her bowl. Typically she eats her bowl completely in a day. I do not leave food available all of the time. She is fed 3 scoops each morning and her bowl is usually empty by the next morning. With this food, she didn't. I didn't add food until the bowl was empty and eventually she ate it all. I also really don't care for the smell of the food myself.