Smells like pepperoni and is soft to touch if you keep bag sealed. It gets hard as a rock after a few days so don’t leave lying around as a later treat. My dog loves them and the big bag is a better deal than buys multiple small bags to equal amount.

We tried several times to order more than 4 of these but could not get more at the sale price. We have 6 dogs that love these treats. Another problem is the package now has less and the price is ridiculous. We are looking for a more reasonably priced treats.

My dogs love this treat. I have a little 7 lb toy poodle and a 14 lb miniature poodle. I split one between the 2 of them. I do have to break the little one's up into small pieces, but the treat is very soft and pliable. They get so excited when they see or hear me get out the bag. I highly recommend this treat and Sam's Club makes it very affordable.

pupperoni for pups..their favorite always!!..several flavors. but orig still the ONE!..even have to break little pieces off for one of 11 cats who bats piece out if my hand while selecting right sized pieces in the large bag for pups!...never order pizza with PUP-PERONI....:)

This is a MUST for my puppers! They LOVE their Pupperoni. It's part of our morning routine. They get treats after I fill their bowls with food. They also get them when they do something outstanding. Bojangles gets SO excited when he sees the red bag come out of the kitchen cabinet!

These are my dog's favorite treat. She begs for (and gets) them daily- twice a day if she can convince someone she hasn't had them yet (and she usually does). They always seem very fresh to me. The smells not bad. She loves all the varieties pup-peroni offers but these are her very favorite. You can't beat Sam's price. I try to catch them on sale and grab a couple bags.

Our new puppy loved these treats. Although they are long, we broke in to smaller pieces and used as training treats. He gets very excited when he hears is getting a treat from the package. Very fresh. Make sure to properly seal or they will get dry and hard

All six of my small breed dogs love this treat. They stay moist and soft. I cut several sticks in small bites size and seal them in a container. But be sure to keep the rest in the re-sealable bag otherwise the sticks will dry and harden over time if left open.

Huskies love these treats

Nice large bag! My dog enjoys them. I’ve never tried them