My 3 dogs really like these. They do have a strong odor typical of salmon.

Made all 3 of my dogs sick.

My dog is obsessed with these, and the ingredient list is pretty simple.

My dog loves these! They are round so we started calling them cookies. Whenever we ask her if she wants a cookie she goes crazy!

This is the only manufactured pet food that I buy for my Newf and he will be 14 next week - pretty good for a large dog.

My Pit loves them.

My 4 legged child is allergic to almost everything. This is one of the very few things he can eat and LOVED by him. Only reason I gave 4 stars, is so dang hard to find it.

My shih-tzus have a number of food sensitivities and are really picky. But they just love these. And I love the simple ingredients and that they aren’t from China.

I have French Bulldogs and they LOVE these! It's also nice that they are soft, and I can break them into smaller pieces easily, as Frenchies do not eat large food/treats.

TJ's sells a salmon and sweet potato treat that my dogs just go nuts for. I don't even have to cut open the bag, they know. And it isn't just my dogs, it is other dogs too. But they are $4 for a 4oz bag and TJ's is about an hour from me. When I saw these, I was intrigued. The ingredients are pretty similar. These contain salmon, sweet potato, vegetable glycerine and mixed tocopherols (preservatives). The TJ's treats contain salmon, sweet potato, vegetable glycerine, rosemary extract, mixed tocopherols and ascorobyl palmitate (preservative). These are about twice the size and are similar to a cracker in texture. The sweet potato is dusted on. The TJ's are softer and resemble a slice of sausage. My dogs were nuts over both. The TJ's treats would be equal to $16 per pound while these come out to $6.66 per pound.