I gave this one star since only one out of my five dogs will eat it. My dogs like fish but not these snacks.

My dog likes it but she eats anything. Other dogs that I tried did not like the fishy smell but most of the dogs liked it. I guess it just depends on how picky your dog is.

PLEASE restock these! It is a great option for dogs with chicken allergies. My dog loved them and there are so few good, affordable options that aren’t chicken!

I bought this product twice and not only does my dog go crazy over this treat but the neighborhood dogs do too. By far this treat is the best for low KCals (14) for each size piece. For less than $20 per 3lb bag this is a also a great deal.

My dog loves these and they are his favorite of all. Please don't discontinue them. They break into smaller pieces easily for smaller dogs and most of the bag once opened can be frozen until more is needed.

Although slightly fishy, my lab loves them! I use these as his high reward treat. They are like a soft baked cookie. I break them up and give him a little here and there.

My 2 dogs are picky eaters but they really like this.

Was not able to find these for awhile Really feel like I'm giving dogs a healthy treat

I love the limited ingredients and my dogs enjoy them. I will buy again.

My dig loves these please keep them in stock!