My dogs L O V E these stinky things!!! I gave a 4 only because from the description on the bag, I thought they would be softer than they are. I have an old guy who doesn't have many teeth.

These are a nice size treat for my dogs. I feel good about giving them since they are limited ingredients with healthy salmon & sweet potatoes, plus extra Omega 3. The price is good considering how much I’m getting. My pups love them!!

These are very scentful! My dogs love them. They are soft. They break easily enough to really get some mileage out of each disc. We use them for all sorts of training exercises.

I love that they're clean without a lot of preservatives. Just be warned, if you don't seal the bag correctly, they will get hard. But that's okay, my dogs love them a little crispier.

My dog really likes these, and I like the ingredients. I tried to order more but they are currently out of stock - hope they will be available again.

These 2" round treats are wonderfull! They smell but don't stink which is a bonus. I'm using them as high-value treats and they fit the bill! Will definitely get more!

My two guys (one a picky eater) love these as part of their breakfast each day. They stand anxiously as I get two or three for each out of the bag. Guess I’ll have to buy more as I’m almost out!

The small size treats are perfect when we like to give our large breed pets treats for alerting us to their need for potty breaks while watching their weight.

My dog loves and my vet approves of the limited ingredients. Four ingredients you can actually pronounce! Plus it’s a fantastic price. Please keep carrying these!

These snacks have stamped crosshatches on them making them easy to break into smaller pieces if needed. They do have a slight fishy smell to them but apparently taste great. My dogs love them.