My dogs love these!! They're picky because I cook liver and chicken, etc., for them but they go crazy for these! (Mastiff and Pit Bull). My friend's dogs do too!

I have ordered these about 10 times. A few months ago I received a bag that looked burnt and smelled sour. They made my dogs sick so I threw that bag away. Just recieved another burnt bag a couple of weeks ago. They went straight into the garbage. Do not recommend.

this was a great product, bought regularly. Product has changed massively as they shrunk the size of bites, dosent smell like samon any longer and has a nasty cardboard consistency when snapping in half. They are no longer soft and the proof is in my dogs will no longer touch it. As usual another good product ruined by being cheap, maybe they thought the dogs wouldn't notice.

Dogs love them.

Excellent

Dogs like them

our dog loved them

Great price.

My dog spit it out

Although slightly fishy, my lab loves them! I use these as his high reward treat. They are like a soft baked cookie. I break them up and give him a little here and there.