Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Select Surfaces Smoked Hickory SpillDefense Laminate Flooring for
Select Surfaces Smoked Hickory SpillDefense Laminate Flooring
4 out of 5 stars
stars
127 ratings70 reviews
  1. 5 stars63% (80)
  2. 4 stars9% (12)
  3. 3 stars6% (8)
  4. 2 stars5% (6)
  5. 1 star17% (21)

Member photos

  • +21 images
Sort by |
Showing 11-20 of 70 reviews
Dec 19, 2021
Reviewer name: sad panda
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

nicks all over

Installed it and it was beautiful. A week later all this nicks show up. It looks awefull. I’ve installed this product before in gray and it was fantastic. This color has major defects. I will have to replace in the next 6 months and I already spent my money on this one. I’m crushed.

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
Mar 9, 2021
Reviewer name: Eriq
3 out of 5 stars
3 out of 5 stars review

Beautiful but scratches easily

This floors looks beautiful, and is easy to install. However I have to say, it chips easily. We’ve only have the floor down for a few weeks and we already have scratches— which is a bit disappointing. And in one place on our floors we have a big gouge! Not sure how it happened because it hasn’t been that long and we’re not particularly hard on these floors.

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Supplier Response

Hello Eriq, Thank you for posting a review. We are sorry to hear about your experience. Because the Elite Collection laminates have an AC4 traffic rating, chipping should not occur with normal residential use. However, it is still important to protect your floor by putting felt pads on your furniture and trying to avoid dragging or dropping heavy objects onto the laminate. Please reach out to us at 1-855-250-8167 or techsupport@selectsurfaces.ca so we can further assist you with this issue. Thank you, Select Surfaces.

May 2, 2022
Reviewer name: Blake S
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Don't buy this flooring!

I spent close to $1800 on this flooring for my upstairs and it's the worst. It chips easy which causes swelling. Edges and taps snap off while laying the floor. Company sucks. I contacted them and they won't honor there 10 year warranty. They say the faults I'm having with the flooring are not due to wear. Go spend your money somewhere else. This flooring is horrible. Sam's won't take it back either because of the time frame policy.

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Select Surfaces

Hello, Thank you for posting a review. We are sorry to hear about your experience. Because the SpillDefense laminates have an AC4 traffic rating, chipping should not occur with normal residential use. However, it is still important to protect your floor by putting felt pads on your furniture and trying to avoid dragging or dropping heavy objects onto the laminate. Please reach out to us at 1-855-250-8167 or techsupport@selectsurfaces.ca so we can further assist you with this issue. Thank you, Select Surfaces

Dec 21, 2020
Reviewer name: Nana Dawn
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

scratches way too easy!!

We have had our floor installed for three weeks, one of which we were out of town. I have seen several nicks in it. I am so disappointed because I have been wanting wood floors for so long! I’m at a loss as what to do, we paid to have it installed and now I don’t know if it will last a year.

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Select Surfaces

Hi. Thank you for writing a review. We're very sorry to hear about your experience. Please send us an email at techsupport@selectsurfaces.ca with photos so that we can help you directly. Thank you, Select Surfaces.

Jan 5, 2022
Reviewer name: Jen
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Beautiful!

We installed this flooring about 6 weeks ago. I was interested in it because of the spill defense. I have 3 corgis that come in sometimes wet from the weather and although we clean up as quick as possible, I still wanted something durable. We absolutely love it! It was the first time laying floor ourselves, but after a little learning curve getting started and watching several videos, it was really easy to install. I will be adding more to other areas of our home.

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Select Surfaces

Hello, We're happy to learn about your positive experience with the Smoked Hickory floor! We would love to see photos of your completed project - you can share them on our website at selectsurfaces.ca. Thank you, Select Surfaces

Apr 7, 2022
Reviewer name: wregle74
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Great Purchase

I have used this laminate in 2 rooms that are high traffic areas in my home and I'm very pleased with the look and durability. I have 4 large dogs and not seen the scratches or chips that I've seen in the other reviews. The laminate is easy to put down and is well worth the money.

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Supplier Response

Hello, It is great to hear that you are enjoying our flooring! We would love to see the finished result. Please feel free to share some photos on our website selectsurfaces.ca/gallery. Thank you, Select Surfaces

Jan 24, 2023
Reviewer name: Lisa M
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

horrible flooring

Worst flooring ever! I love the color and how it looks but this flooring chips like crazy. Unfortunately we’re stuck with it for now in our family room and kitchen and there’s chipping everywhere after only two months. Luckily we were able to return the rest before we installed in the rest of our house. Do not buy! It is the worst.

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Supplier Response

Hello, Thank you for posting a review. All our SpillDefense Collection laminates have an AC4 rating, making it suitable for heavy residential and light commercial use. Because Smoked Hickory has an AC4 traffic rating, chipping should not occur with normal residential use. However, it is still important to protect your floor by putting felt pads on your furniture and trying to avoid dragging or dropping heavy objects onto the laminate. Please reach out to us at 1-855-250-8167 or techsupport@selectsurfaces.ca so we can further assist you with this issue. Thank you, Select Surfaces

Dec 22, 2021
Reviewer name: CC
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed!!

Purchased this flooring for entire home excluding bathrooms. Upon installation contractors warned us about how easily the color chips off. With the thickness of the flooring I thought there would be more wood instead of foam backing. From the scratches that we have, the “woodgrain texture” is extremely thin! Buyer beware. Oh and it’s just me and my husband, no children or pets. I wouldn’t purchase this flooring again due to the fragility of it. Very disappointed!

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Supplier Response

Hello, We are sorry to hear about your experience. We measure the wear layer according to the Abrasion Rating System, not the thickness. All our SpillDefense Collection laminates have an AC4 rating, making it suitable for heavy residential and light commercial use. Because Smoked Hickory has an AC4 traffic rating, chipping should not occur with normal residential use. However, it is still important to protect your floor by putting felt pads on your furniture and trying to avoid dragging or dropping heavy objects onto the laminate. Please reach out to us at 1-855-250-8167 or techsupport@selectsurfaces.ca so we can further assist you with this issue. Thank you, Select Surfaces

Mar 13, 2022
Reviewer name: Marcy Raddish
1 out of 5 stars
1 out of 5 stars review

We have installed flooring in our home, my mothers home, both my sons homes and a rental and this is the worst laminate ever!!!! It nicks and scratches so easy. No of the other floors have any scratches on them! If this would have my first laminate floor it would have been the last! So much time and energy wasted installing it!

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Select Surfaces

Hello, Thank you for posting a review. We are sorry to hear about your experience. Because the SpillDefense laminates have an AC4 traffic rating, chipping should not occur with normal residential use. However, it is still important to protect your floor by putting felt pads on your furniture and trying to avoid dragging or dropping heavy objects onto the laminate. Please reach out to us at 1-855-250-8167 or techsupport@selectsurfaces.ca so we can further assist you with this issue. Thank you, Select Surfaces

May 1, 2022
Reviewer name: Marie
5 out of 5 stars
5 out of 5 stars review

Beautiful floor

We installed six month ago. We have ten people in our home. 6 are kids plus a big dog who often needs a nail trim. It has no scratches, and we have an active family. It has stood up to even scooters, roller blades, hoverboards with not a mark. Cleans up beautifully with a steam cleaner! I could not be happier!

Helpful?4SIBMNH0FPN614182219761
reply from Supplier Response

Hello, thank you for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled to hear that you love your new flooring. We would love to see photos of your completed project - you can share them on selectsurfaces.ca/gallery or tag us on social media at OfficialSelectSurfaces. Thank you, Select Surfaces