Our dog would not eat the food, but in fairour dog is a very picky eater. You may have better luck with your dogs. I gave it a 3 out of as a neutral rating.

This is the equivalent of Caesar's brand. The texture is kind of watery and more bland. My dogs eat it well but not as enthusiastic as with the Caesar's. The price is almost half so I would say if your dog is not picky you'll be ok.

It’s not for our family dog. He loves ceasor but absolutely will not eat the member mark. We tried it for the cost savings, but not worth it for him not to touch it.

We received a package of Member's Mark pate style dog food to sample and review. My dogs love it, and the single-serving portions are very convenient. The list of ingredients makes me feel comfortable feeding it to my dogs.

I’m not a fan of pate dog food, but this product is great! No strong smell and picky Yorkie loves it! I prefer it over Little Caesar and hope Sam’s continues to carry it, even if it’s only available online. It’s a household staple for us!

Tried this brand since it was less expensive than Caesar, however, our dog doesn’t like it. It appears to be the same, but I guess she’s picky. But then, she’s 16 years old.

Our dog loved this food and even tried licking the container. It's not quite as firm as other pate dog food and leaves a little more food in his beard.

I was hoping it would be like the Cesar dog food. The consistency is too soft and mushy. My dog tried it and didn't care for it at all. Please don't replace Cesar dog food with this product, it's not the same.

I received a box of the Members Mark Pate Style dog food and was leery on changing my Yorkies diet to an unknown food. I was pleasantly surprised how much they liked this food. They love both flavors. The containers are the perfect size and convenient to serve.

I have one dog that ate it right away and loved it but threw up later that day. Then I waited a week and gave him it again thinking it might have been something else, and he threw up again. Both times after eating the Turkey pate. My other dog would not touch it. Unfortunately. I gave it to my friend who breeds yorkies and said her dogs wouldn't touch it either. The texture seemed to mushy. My dogs are used to Ceasar brand and I really wanted to switch since it is too expensive. But this is not a good choice my dogs.