My dog didn't like them. He'll eat them but they are very hard & extremely crunchy for the dog. Leaves a mess be hind of small pieces.

These things weren't quite what i expected. They last longer than a standard treat i suppose, but it is just a treat. It's not a long lasting distraction for heavy chewers.

I have three Pitbulls that just go wild for these. They are spoiled rotten and are picky eaters. But man when they see this bag that just give us the pitiful face. They absolutely love them.

Great treat for small to large dogs. Very crunchy but not too hard to hurt teeth, Very easy to break so you can divide for dogs depending on size. I have ordered these often and have never had a problem with them.

Just bought these for my two 90+ lb German Shepherds and they loved these! Only lasted 2-3 minutes but unlike bully sticks I don’t have to worry about that last 3 inches of the sticks laying in their stomach. About to order a couple more bags!

While my dog did seem to enjoy these, I will never buy them again because they smell so bad I had to hold my breath to get one out of the bag. I gave 3 stars because he did seem to like them.

I got these for my Shepard, and he refuses to eat them, and he eats everything!

My dog loves these beef sticks! I will continue to give him these as a treat. I love the fact that the ingredients list has 1 ingredient, beef.

I'm so glad I found these! I think it's their favorite of ALL time. Please try to keep them in stock

Had to return, my dog got her gums cut because the treat is hollow, and when it's bitten, it breaks into sharp edges.