This is the preferred treat for our 4 pups! They have enjoyed Blue Buffalo Nudges for years, but after finding this simple ingredient product, I decided to give it a try. When offered both treats, all 4 dogs pick this first!

My dogs love these dearly. I have one dog (Husky Mix) that is extremely picky and he will take these every time they are offered. I have now found when my neighbors dogs are barking (mean and not nice), throw them one of these and they've become a lot nicer! Now my next door neighbor's dog is coming over to get one! I'm guessing they are putting the word out in the neighborhood that we're the treat house. LOL

These appear to be the same as the Members Mark beef stick from a few years ago. My Great Pyrenees love those and seeps to love these as well. I use these as a special treat when I have to medicate her ear. I give her half, however she'd eat the entire pack if I let her. Amazon has these a for 2.5 times the price. It's crazy. I really hope they keep them in stock this time

Not what I thought they were. They are dehydrated. So they are crispy I was under the impression they were soft . It leaves cribs everywhere on my carpet that’s like gravel not nice to step in . My dog doesn’t care for these like the other treats he has . He loves regular meat sticks . He will leave this all day and eat out of desperation. Might just keep in emergency food storage food since they will last longer .

Irish Rover changed the recipe! These beef sticks are not the same as before. I was buying this once a month. And I bought them for other people's dogs. They are now a choking hazard. The stick my dogs teeth and mouth and my dogs almost choked on these! They are not hard like before! They are very soft and almost like a sticky caramel. Very disappointed because my dogs loved these beef sticks.

I was so excited to find 100% All Beef treats for my kids! However, when I got home and opened the bag, they smelled horrific like PURE CHEMICALS and Maneuverer. I tried giving them to my dogs, one ate it and got sick for a day, and the other refused to eat it. So, I returned them right back to Sam's Club.

My four dogs hated these - consistency of coral reef. Very hard and crumbly. I appreciate that they are simple ingredients, beef only, but the way they are cooked or cured needs some work. I had to return these which is super rare - my doodles love everything.

While they look like bully sticks, they are not. They are a foam like substance, extruded like a Cheeto, mostly air. They shatter into tiny pieces when bitten, making a mess. For $20, I and my dog expected more substantial. For all its size it last only 10 or 15 seconds for my large dog. The cleanup takes longer. The Purina Busy Bones are a better buy!

These are a great treat for my dogs.

Excellent product glad to see it back