My four dogs hated these - consistency of coral reef. Very hard and crumbly. I appreciate that they are simple ingredients, beef only, but the way they are cooked or cured needs some work. I had to return these which is super rare - my doodles love everything.

Dog Beef Stick

Our dogs like them.

My dog loves this

The dogs love these!

My pup loves these

My Dogs love them

Dogs absolutely love it

My dog big girl just loves these. I really like the fact that they tell how much and how often to feed them. I can break the stick in smaller pieces for my two smaller dogs.

In the picture and packaging I didn't notice if it said the Beef Sticks are soft or hard but they are super hard almost like wood hard. My doggie didn't seem to like it at first but after a while he started to break it off and eat it. This snack will be one of his last snack to go to.