Irish Rover changed the recipe! These beef sticks are not the same as before. I was buying this once a month. And I bought them for other people's dogs. They are now a choking hazard. The stick my dogs teeth and mouth and my dogs almost choked on these! They are not hard like before! They are very soft and almost like a sticky caramel. Very disappointed because my dogs loved these beef sticks.

I was so excited to find 100% All Beef treats for my kids! However, when I got home and opened the bag, they smelled horrific like PURE CHEMICALS and Maneuverer. I tried giving them to my dogs, one ate it and got sick for a day, and the other refused to eat it. So, I returned them right back to Sam's Club.

the first bag we bought these were excellent. they had a nice chew to them so our dog could chew them a bit not just woof them down. to snap them in half too some effort. the 2nd batch we bought, awful. dry brittle like a pretzel stick. wrote to the company, no reply at all.

Dogs enjoy the savory beef sticks every time.

Very crunchy and breaks apart making it more fun and yummy for the pups

My small dog loves them she is a papillon. They don't last long because they are like freeze dried.

Excellent product glad to see it back

They are good for chewers! They aren’t soft and have a strong kinda weird smell.

My Great Pyrenees dogs love these treats. I highly recommend them.

The pups love these treats,