I have two dogs, both large, one dog likes them all the time, the other dog who is more finicky likes them some of the time. So it's a hit or miss.

My dogs loved this treat. They both hold it upright while taking a bite. My hound play and hide it for a minute before eating .

They are very crunchy and crumbley. My pit inhaled her(like she does everything), my other one love them and take their time crunching away.

I have been waiting forever for these to come back. I’m so happy they have. They are longer lasting than a normal treat and my dogs love them!

My dogs love these, doesn't irritate the sensitive stomach a couple have. Doesn't last long but that's okay

My dog's (both giant dogs) love these. They are a great alternative to the old Members Mark Beef Sticks that they no longer sell.

Very popular with my dog. 1/2 a stick per day. Unfortunate shape snd color when it is sitting on the carpet.

These are great and my dogs love them. These are beef sticks and my dogs want one every day. These are freeze dried and only beef nothing else.

These are extremely dry and crunch up so the dog can leave pieces all over the floor. They don’t smell the greatest either.

Big dog will eat them. If I try to give to small dogs they walk away. Even if I break them in pieces