These are very brittle and sharp splinter when my dog would chew them. They are just not good for my dog. She loved the taste i was just worried about the brittleness not being digested correctly.

I cannot say enough about these beef sticks. My dog goes nuts for them. I hope that Sam's continues to stock them because I buy multiple bags for my pup.

We have four large dogs who loved these. Great crunch, no trouble digesting them. Only reason for 4 stars is the small pieces left over when the dogs were done. Those hurt to step on!

I love there isn’t anything artificial about it! My (4) Golden Retrievers love them!! They give them a paws up! (Only because they don’t have thumbs 😂)

I follow instructions to give a small portion and she got the diarrhea. She is a German Shepherd and I have given similar treats and never got sick like this treat

My German Shepherds love these treats. They are crunch and satisfying for them. It doesn't last them long but they love it as their dinner treat. I'm sad that our store doesn't carry it anymore. I hope I can still order it online.

Our dog loves these, we've ordered 2 haha before, but this latest bag they are only about a third as long as we are used to getting. I'm hoping this is a fluke

We give these to our dog when we’re going to be gone for a few hours. It doesn’t Last very long but is a great distraction when we’re trying to get out of the house.

Sorry as soon as I opened the package I had to return them. I knew by just seeing them they weren’t for my dogs. I even bought two, should have known when I saw they were on clearance! No good for dogs

I thought these would be chews, like something my dog could work on, but they’re not. They’re quite brittle. My dog enjoys them but I worry that they will shatter while she’s chewing them. I can snap them into pieces with ease. Very brittle.