My dogs love these. I have one average chewer and one aggressive chewer. They finish them in 10-15 minutes. They are very digestible, and I've never had an issue. They do not stain carpets.

My American Bulldog loves these. When he gets one, he is completely concentrated on crunching them up. This is a special treat. He doesn't get one every day.

I was very happy to find these at Sam's as I had been buying them in much smaller and more expensive packs of 4 at a time for my American bulldog and my pitbull. They love them and the collagen is really good for their coats and joints.

My dog loves this treat. He can't wait to get one. He loves them so much that he will sit in front of the package until we give him a snack. If it were up to him, this would be his diet.

It took a bit for my dogs to actually try them but now they love them. I give them to the dogs if I'm going to be gone for a while. It's a nice treat to keep them busy for a bit.

Having small dogs, I planned to cut into smaller pieces. Only with pliers and screwdriver can I pry off pieces. My husband with hand pruning shears isn’t able to cut them. Dogs do like the few pieces been able to remove I would not buy again

It is a great deal and a treat for your pet but unfortunately I did notice when my pup pooped it has a really strong unpleasant smell and even when she chews on it it does not smell good.

My dogs LOVE these! I have a super-chewer (White Lab) and one who savors his chews. Both can eat through the chew in about 15-30 minutes. But they love them so much they will turn up their noses to other treats offered. Maybe a bit spoiled?

not right for my dogs. These gave my dogs upset stomachs. They also didn't last very long for them to eat, and they had near choking and coughing from them.

Our big dogs love these, but owners not so much. They break up into very small pieces and we end up just cleaning up after they eat this treat. No fun. As far as the dogs go, it’s a tasty yummy treat for them. Great for heavy chewers, but messy.