It took a bit for my dogs to actually try them but now they love them. I give them to the dogs if I'm going to be gone for a while. It's a nice treat to keep them busy for a bit.

I got these for my dog as an alternative to rawhide. I have given her 2 and both times she choked or hacked when she ate it. I also noticed she went right for her water. I don't think they're safe and don't want it hurting her.

My dog loves these things! The only reason I am giving a lower score is because my carpet does not love these things. I get red circles where my dog chews the treat.

I have 4 large dogs all over 50 pounds and they will gather under the shelf to let me know that they are expecting their treat and looking up at them. They grab the sticks and run off to their favorite spot to enjoy them.

My dog loved them. Didn’t take as long for him to chew up as I would like but not all dogs are the same. They keep him occupied for about 20 minutes. I will purchase again.

My dogs really enjoy these and i like that they are not made of rawhide. I wish they came in different sizes. My 100 pound dogs love them and my 16 pound dogs stare longingly at the big dogs while the treats are being eaten.

These are an excellent chew item for any large dog. My Ridgeback loves these chews and could eat a whole bag in a day or so if he had the chance. Priced at just a little less than $1 each.

Our dog Marlin, a Goldendoodle, thoroughly enjoys these. They're more brittle than I thought they would be - I was thinking they'd last longer and be more chewy. Overall, I would buy them again. Just keep an eye on your pup when they have one.

Our dog’s loved them and we gave them a bone twice a day and they had the bag ate within a week. Our dog are large and super chewers. If you have a smaller dog they should last longer.

I treat these outside because they will break into little bits and if your pup isn't the cleanest, it can be a pain to clean up. Outside, I don't have a problem, and my pup loves these treats.