The pup loves these, but they are a long of little compressed bits, so when he eats then there's is a huge pile of crumbs when he's done. Based on the size, I thought they'd occupy him for a while, but nope. He eats one in a couple minutes. I made the mistake of letting him bring one on the couch! What a mess!

These are a treat NOT a chew. Takes my dog all of two minutes to consume one and that includes all the time it takes her to find all the little pieces when the roll shatters into tiny little fragments. Glad she likes them, but I won't be buying again. They don't last long enough and they make a mess.

My bulldogs LOVE these. Every night they go to the cabinet where I store them and put their nose on the cabinet door. When I go towards the cabinet they start twisting all around. They grab one a piece and both go separate directions.

The 1st time I bought these my dog wouldn't eat them. I had to squish cheese into all the nooks and cranies. This batch she can't wait to munch on. Thanks for the update and the sale.

Purchased these for my dog as a treat. He loves them! He takes them outside and plays wi0th thgem before eating them. Will defimnitely be buying these again.

Very messy, these crumble like a cracker and make a huge mess. The bag is gigantic so now my dog only gets these outside. They are brittle and dont last but 10 minutes. Wish I never wasted the money on em

My 4 dogs disliked the product. My adopted dogs are each of a different breed type, however, all of them did not take to the flavor of these bully rolls.

This is a high quality product. I have a very active dog and enjoy that this is a rawhide alternative and has collagen. My dog truly enjoys this treat and it’s good for him!

Our little guy likes them, but we can tell they are not his favorite. Given a choice he chooses the dental chews.

My Pointer is high energy and loves to jump. She gets 1 of these daily to help her stay healthy. She gets so excited when she knows it's time for her collagen roll. Its her favorite treat.