I have 2 dogs around 50 pounds each. I wanted to try treat that might keep them busy and last. We had to take them away from them after 2 or 3 bites they had half of the treat gone. The problem I have is the pieces were braking off were sharp almost like bones.

My three German Shepherds absolutely love these treats! I give each of them one every day and they look forward to it. They remind me when it is time. They do a great job of keeping their teeth clean. I was worried one time when my Sam's store was out of them, so I stack them deep. I dread the day they stop carrying them.

The pup loves these, but they are a long of little compressed bits, so when he eats then there's is a huge pile of crumbs when he's done. Based on the size, I thought they'd occupy him for a while, but nope. He eats one in a couple minutes. I made the mistake of letting him bring one on the couch! What a mess!

My dog is over 100 lbs. He really enjoys these and makes short work of them. I like that they are good for him, they do however make a really big mess.

Dogs loved them but gave them diarrhea. Tried them twice with the same result. Will be returning them.

these are ok the dogs 'sort of' like them but for what they cost they should have better ingredients

Great for my dog when he was a puppy, however when he got his adult teeth they went very quickly! Doesn't stop my boy from loving them though!! Golden retriever for reference.

This is the one thing I NEED to be able to find every time I come to Sam’s club! My dog loves these! I love them, too, because there are many healthy benefits. They also seem to help keep his teeth clean because his teeth look great.

Our dog likes these. They’re a quick treat. They’re chewed up and gone in a couple of seconds. They don’t keep a dog busy chewing for a long time so they are good for a quick treat when you can’t supervise your fur baby at length.

My senior pups loves treats, she knows when she comes in she gets something. She likes these and it so much better than rawhide bones. I love knowing it's good for her too