These are a treat NOT a chew. Takes my dog all of two minutes to consume one and that includes all the time it takes her to find all the little pieces when the roll shatters into tiny little fragments. Glad she likes them, but I won't be buying again. They don't last long enough and they make a mess.

I gave each of my dogs one every afternoon when I got home from work. They crumble a bit, so I gave it to them to eat outside. I always had two very happy dogs, who of course always wanted more. I hope you carry this product in the future. I will buy them again!!!!

The pup loves these, but they are a long of little compressed bits, so when he eats then there's is a huge pile of crumbs when he's done. Based on the size, I thought they'd occupy him for a while, but nope. He eats one in a couple minutes. I made the mistake of letting him bring one on the couch! What a mess!

It’s a great find!

I have 2 dogs around 50 pounds each. I wanted to try treat that might keep them busy and last. We had to take them away from them after 2 or 3 bites they had half of the treat gone. The problem I have is the pieces were braking off were sharp almost like bones.

these broke up like chunks of wood - they looked like tanbark pieces when my dog was chewing on them

Massive dog craps everywhere. Don’t give these to them. DANGER! DANGER! DOG POOP IN BOUND!

Dogs loved them but gave them diarrhea. Tried them twice with the same result. Will be returning them.

My K9s love these like these are the original Scooby snacks i like giving them to them because they are collagen and i guess it good for them

Our little guy likes them, but we can tell they are not his favorite. Given a choice he chooses the dental chews.