My dog's love them but they don't last very long. The purpose of a chew is to satisfy a dog's chewing needs but these are just a treat that last a couple of minutes.

I was hoping these were going to be more like a bully stick and chewy. These are hard and crumbly. Makes a mess on the floor. The dog likes them. But there’s not much he doesn’t like.

They don't last long, but my pup seems to love the taste of these chews and gobbles them up! It does alleviate her cravings to chew for a while too. Recommend!

I have a dog that had pancreatic issues as a pup, have had her safe and sound but we lack for treats that she really likes. Enough with the sweet potatoes already--I will slowly introduce these to her and hope they do not do her harm--adds say they will not but no one can believe the adds anymore.

My lab loves these! They are big, and obviously tasty as he gets excited when he hears the bag crinkle and knows he’s getting a treat. They are a good value for the money as you get twice the product or more than you would comparable products in the grocery store for the same price.

I have two Italian greyhounds,they absolutely love these. Made my youngest girl who normally waits for her older sister to leave her her scraps a bully. Hence the name! After there first one they now share. I have cream carpet and they don’t leave a mess from there dark color.

BUYER BEWARE: These bones cost us almost $3000 because our dog ended up with an intestinal obstruction and had to have surgery for it to be removed. The vet removed a “orange ball of gummy goo” that she is almost positive came from this bone. Our dog loved the bone, but I thank God that he only had one before we figured out what was happening. This bag of bones is going directly in the garbage. I would give these bones a negative million stars if possible.

My GSD loves these. He gets one when we leave the house for long periods of time. He goes straight to his bed and doesn't seem as anxious when we leave. Gives him something else to focus on (although not for long. He's a big boy!). I keep them on hand at all times.

I have not been able to find these anywhere that are as cheap as Sam Club offers. They are a game changer with my little pup who is hyper and naughty in the evening hours. My husband cuts them in half making it perfect for our other small dog as well, who has stomach troubles, however these chews don't upset her tum whatsoever. We hope Sams Club continues to carry these!

Great treat that works great for my aggressive chewers. They only last a few minutes. Unlike other types of chews, there has never been any choking associated with the collagen chew. I feel very comfortable giving these to my dogs and they LOVE them.