4 starts because my 9mo old corgi loves them! -1 star because they are supposed to last 2x more than rawhide, my pup destroys them in less than 20 min. 10/10. They smell absolutely disgusting but he loves it so I'm happy

These are big treats. My border collie got sick from eating this but he might be intolerant of the collagen.. they splinter into large pieces so I suggest supervision at first if you're dog woofs years down fast.

not right for my dogs. These gave my dogs upset stomachs. They also didn't last very long for them to eat, and they had near choking and coughing from them.

Just too big for my 30lb dog. Next day after chewing on it he had diarrhea-only thing different in diet. Threw giant bag in trash. Shouldn’t have bought to try from Sam’s.

Our dog likes these. They’re a quick treat. They’re chewed up and gone in a couple of seconds. They don’t keep a dog busy chewing for a long time so they are good for a quick treat when you can’t supervise your fur baby at length.

Our 3 big dogs absolutely LOVE these bones. They are crunchy (which is great for their teeth) and it’s a good treat for them when we’re leaving the house to keep them occupied for a few minutes.

They are good quality bones however, the have reduced the bone size by 1/4 from the original. No wonder they are now discounted. I will purchase on occasion but not regularly.

Both of my dogs vomited and have the runs after giving them these. Both husky malamute mix. One is 4 yrs old & 100lb and the other 10 months old & 50lbs

I don't know much about them. They're for my dog. He don't like them. They end up looking like some wood bark with a little flavor coating on them. He can't seem to finish them. He won't tell me why.

Bits and pieces of it all over the floor and bed. When the dogs chew it it crumbles and there's bits and pieces everywhere. A lot of cleaning duty for me. I will not buy it again.