I was hoping these were going to be more like a bully stick and chewy. These are hard and crumbly. Makes a mess on the floor. The dog likes them. But there’s not much he doesn’t like.

Bought these to give our dogs a different treat. Both dogs love them and will dance around and get super excited when they see they are getting them. They are always gone within 2 minutes of receiving them (our dogs are German Shepard and German Shepard mix). I have since bought them again not only from Sam's but also in a smaller, thinner size. We will be purchasing again and again to keep these furry critters happy.

I have a nine month old hound who is an aggressive chewer. She tends to swallow chunks of things that are quite large but I watched her carefully with these rolls and she chews them up into small pieces before she swallows them. They have not given her any digestive problems

I have two Italian greyhounds,they absolutely love these. Made my youngest girl who normally waits for her older sister to leave her her scraps a bully. Hence the name! After there first one they now share. I have cream carpet and they don’t leave a mess from there dark color.

My GSD loves these. He gets one when we leave the house for long periods of time. He goes straight to his bed and doesn't seem as anxious when we leave. Gives him something else to focus on (although not for long. He's a big boy!). I keep them on hand at all times.

My german wire hair loves these rolls! They last longer than his typical treats, although they are still gone in about 20 minutes. I typically give him one or two a week as a special treat. Wish Sam's carried the same product in a size appropriate for my Havanese.

My dog loves these chew sticks. The collagen is great for a large dog breed that is still growing even at an already weight of 100#. I also like that they aren't rawhide as my last dog would chew for a while and then just swallow large pieces of them.

I have purchased these rolls several times before and this was my first time ordering them to ship to my home. The two packages of TruRanch Collagen Rolls were smashed, torn and the rolls were everywhere. Not sure if I can trust these rolls to give to my dogs. It looks like they were tossed in the box from 50 yards away. Then the case of mushrooms were tossed on top.

My dogs love these, but they chew them extremely fast. My dogs are 30ish lbs, 6%267 years old. They chew through them in maaaaaybe 5 minutes. I wouldn’t mind so much, but they get horrible gas and big poops with them also. So now, when they eat them (they do love them and I don’t want to waste them) I cut them in half. And they each get part of it. Helps with the gas/poos. I will not buy them again though. We usually give them single ingredient collagen chews, but ran out and tried these. If we didn’t have to live with the horrible gas, I would buy them again probably. But no thanks lol.

These are a good bulk option for a no nonsense treat that can keep your dog entertained for a short while- even my enthusiastic youngster takes 10-15 minutes to chew this. I would rate it higher but my old cattle dog chews them but isn’t very excited about them, I’m not sure if they hurt her teeth or if it’s that they aren’t strong in flavor. That said they won’t leave your dog with a stinky face and that is nice.