Dog loves them, and prefers them over other treats. Bought these to increase calorie intake with protEin and fat, in a US-made product. These fill the bill as a treat.

My over active heelers whose job it is to fetch tennis balls look forward to this beefy treat. They hardly stop to chew these yummy ( to them) treats.

My 3 yr old German Shepard loves these and my 8 yr old Shih Tzu / Yorkie also loves these however I have to cut them in smaller pieces I use these as reward treats

I am returning these. They made my dog sick. He's 14 and has never used the bathroom in the house before. He threw up, peed and had diarrhea all over the house in the middle of the night and was lethargic.

My dogs will not eat it

Top quality dog treats that are good for him.

This treat did not go well with either dog I own, causing diarrhea for both.

Okay but not as good as the large beef sticks my very large dogs loved more.

Wish it was a little softer but my small dog loves them

Not what I expected, will not buy again.