My dog loves them

My Danes love these

The dogs love it!

It used to be perfect, fresh and moist, but now it is super dry and crumbly. Really hope it's just a fluke and that Members Mark didn't change the formula or cheap out.

My dogs used to love these treats but the last time I bought them they looked and felt like cardboard. I returned them and got a good bag…now they all look like cardboard. What have you done?

They stopped carrying the grain free dog biscuits I always bought in store, so my husband picked these up. I did not approve of the when he brought them home, but we tried them out. Dogs loved them, but gave both dogs continued diarrhea. In the trash they go and will just have to special order the others. Please bring the grain free simple ingredient dog biscuits back to the store, and send these crappy ones to the graveyard. How could you keep selling these seeing that they are causing digestive issues in so many dogs?! Come on Sam's, get with the times. Stop selling poison.

I am very picky about what my dogs eat. I bought these thinking they would be a healthy alternative. I gave you to my dogs for about 3 days all of a sudden their poop looks like sand not solid at all this is like poison do not feed this to your dogs. please look into getting some free dried liver.

bought these treats for my dog, and by the third day of having them, she became very sick with vomiting and diarrhea. I had to rush her to the vet, and they believe the treats upset her stomach since it was the only change in her diet. I would not recommend these treats.

First time trying and they are a hit with my boxers!

Too expensive for what you get.