The consistency has changed. They used to be thinner and longer. The last couple of bags have been thicker and shorter. I break them to place on top of food and use for treats. I prefer the thinner shape. My dogs do not discriminate.

My dogs love them. And they don't have a bunch of extra junk in the ingredients. I will continue to buy them. Hopefully they don't discontinue them anytime soon.

Thank you for getting these Treats. My 2 dogs have allergies and these have been a great blessing to us. Bonus was that they are made in the US. please keep these always.

My dogs actually love these. They smell like real beef. And they're soft. I have to put them up so somebody doesn't sneak in and pull the bag down and eat the entire bag!

Good dog tests. My dog loves then. I wish the pieces were a little bigger because she's a large breed. For normal size or small dogs they are perfect.

My dogs love it

Picky dogs love this

Dogs love them

Our dog loves these

Great product