Can't taste the peanut butter in the cookie. They seemed to have changed the mixes. For many, many years my favorites were Peanut Butter and also Oatmeal Chocolate Chip but even it is way different now and much more bland. I hate to say it but they've destroyed the product and I will have to move on. So disappointing.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] If I could give this 10 stars I would because I love Betty Crocker peanut butter cookies so much. I use them every single year at Christmas time to make my peanut butter blossoms and they come out amazing every single time!!

Betty Crocker has printed their directions wrong on these December 2023 cookie packages. 1 month ago they tasted way different. Turns out there should only be 2 tablespoons of vegetable oil—not 3 according to my package. Why can’t you recall these and let people know?

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I love the easy preparation and not to many added ingredients. The cookies does take to bake. The cookies are very good and soft to taste. The second the are still soft. It a good snack to satisfy you sweet tooth.

I have yet to find a peanut butter cookie recipe that completely fits the bill.  After trying for so long I gave up and tried this mix and now just use it anytime I want peanut butter cookies.  Super easy and tastes great!  Highly suggest if you need a quick fix or are just not a baker.  This is one that really does compare to ones from scratch.  

This is my go to when I need a quick dessert.  Granted I always "doctor" (ie. add chocolate chips to or use as a crust/base for bar cookies, etc.) recipes.  But my very vocal adult sons have never had a complaint.  I usually don't rate/comment but I was so surprised at the comments I felt the need.

I love baking cookies, but I never managed to master a good peanut butter cookie! These work well; just make sure not to overbake or they will be really dry and crumbly. The price is right and they hit the spot. Do yourself a favor and dip them in chocolate too!!

I have always loved Betty Crocker's peanut butter cookie mix. It is extremely easy to make. They're chewy, and lightly crumbly. They have rich peanut butter taste there is nothing like eating these with a cold glass of milk, while they're lightly warm.

Love the Betty Crocker mixes for a quick treat. Whips up in minutes and the directions are clear and exact. The cookies come out perfectly with a lovely peanut butter flavour. I do find the cookies are a tad too sweet so I would suggest Betty Crocker cuts down some of the sugar in the recipe.

I always buy this cookie mix as well as a bag of Reese's Peanut Butter Chips 10 oz and mix the chips in to this mix prepared by the instructions. Theyre the best peanut butter cookies ever! Not quite as good as homemade but the best youll find in a bag!