I used these around Christmas time and they were delicious! Everyone thought I had made them from scratch. They were hard on the outside and soft on the inside.

If you omit a little liquid and replace it with actual chunky peanut butter you will have the absolute very best PB cookies you have ever eaten and extremely easy to make! Don't flatten them out and they're even better! Heavenly mounds haha!

We love the quantity of cookie bags we get in these Betty Crocker boxes from Sam’s. When we buy, we know we are set for awhile! The freshness and the ease of directions ( large print directions on the box for elderly eyes is a big plus) is super helpful! They taste great with right amount of ingredients to make peanut butter cookies delicious! We buy two boxes every holiday season to make our holiday cookies and we always get lots of compliments. Plus, they are available for curb side pick up which super helps in a hectic time of year!

Excellent & EASY!! If you really want an unbelievably good peanut butter sandwich…… add a little bit of additional melted butter to the mix (it makes it easier for stirring in the extra peanut butter you’ve just added). Then - yep, just like making a normal peanut butter sandwich, between the two pieces of bread (or cookies) you have to have some peanut butter. Not only are they fun to eat, they’re fun to give away.

Love these cookies and amazing price. Thrilled to get these so cheap. Varying adds to plain PB cookie. Add kisses or put dough into small muffin pans and when almost done I push a mini Reese’s cup into the center of each dough. Delicious easy to take somewhere for parties or various things.

The directions, while printed rather small, were spot on. I don’t understand the “wishy-washy” reviews! I got 31 decent sized cookies, plopped a Hershey kiss on each one, worked perfectly. I’m happy to have dessert for company this weekend. I will purchase this and other flavors in the future. Thank you for an easy to make cookie!

Really do taste like old schol home made peanut butter cookies.

These are so easy to make, and they taste delicious, but I'm downgrading the rating to four because the box keeps shrinking, there are no longer Hershey's kisses inside, there are now only three bags instead of four, and the price keeps increasing.

Made exactly as directed and am very disappointed with the end result. No distinguishable peanut or peanut butter taste, overly sweet leaving a faint oily residue in my mouth. I do not recommend. Make your own cookies using real and wholesome ingredients rather than this mix of lab-made products.

I'm not sure if they changed the ingredients, or miscalculated the expiration date. But it was absolutely disgusting! The mud pies we made as kids might have been better. Hopefully it was just the box we got. I've been cooking for 43 years, so it was a genuine surprise when even the dough tasted stale.