Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Hotel Premier Memory Foam Mattress, Available in Medium, Firm, and Ultra Plush for
Member's Mark Hotel Premier Memory Foam Mattress, Available in Medium, Firm, and Ultra Plush
4.3 out of 5 stars
stars3,353 ratings1,521 reviews
  1. 5 stars69% (2,330)
  2. 4 stars12% (418)
  3. 3 stars6% (210)
  4. 2 stars4% (126)
  5. 1 star8% (269)

Member photos

  • +79 images
Sort by |
Showing 551-560 of 1,521 reviews
Feb 27, 2021
Shopallthetime2
1 out of 5 stars review

HORRIBLE HORRIBLE ODOR WORST DECISION EVER!

The musty chemical smell is has been just absolutely horrible. I have been sleeping on this mattress a month and it still smells. I'm have been waking up with headaches since day one from the smell. Plus with the poor support you sink down in it to far. I don't recommend this Hotel 12" Premier Queen mattress and I would love to return it!

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
Dec 3, 2023
Gaby
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Mattress

Very comfortable

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
Dec 26, 2025
SHAWNA
2 out of 5 stars review

Size does Matter

I purchased 2 Twin XL 12" medium mattresses to use with a King platform bed. While the mattresses expanded quickly, had no smell, and a perfect medium feel (not too soft/not too firm), they are not anywhere close to a Twin XL dimensions (38" x 80"). Within 15 minutes of unboxing, they each expanded to nearly 42" wide. Height only got to about 11" as well. 84" wide will not work on a 76 1/2" wide bed. I ordered online so they will be picked up, but it was a complete pain to have to plastic them up again for pick up.

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
Feb 9, 2023
Savannah
2 out of 5 stars review

Poorly marketed 10 INCH mattress

I had such high hopes for this mattress as I am a big time lover of the Members Mark brand.. however, this mattress did not prove its 4.5 star review. I tried to give it the benefit of the doubt despite seeing reviews about the mattress only inflating to 10 inches but that has proven true in my case as well. The edges of the mattress remained compressed and the cover fabric was loose due to the lack of foam inflation. Sadly I will be returning this mattress.

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
May 26, 2021
Angel
3 out of 5 stars review

Lives up to the name

Had this mattress now for about 3days. It’s exactly what it states itself to be as a “hotel premier” mattress. Now let me explain. Have you ever been to a hotel and the beds are really soft, whether through years of use or the type of mattress it is? Well this is exactly that. Can I get into bed and knock out? Yessir! However in my case, I wake up with super back pains. I typically sleep on a firm bed due to the back pain I have from an old injury. Don’t believe the line of “medium firm” it’s more like “cloud soft” so keep that in mind. My review is neutral due to me being able to just fall asleep instantly which is something I don’t normally do. If you want the fluff this is for you, if you want something rock hard then don’t count on this to be it.

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
Nov 3, 2020
Reno
2 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Disappointed somewhat

I was disappointed with my new mattress. I thought I was buying a conventional type mattress and was surprised when I received it . It was described as a hotel type mattress but i having never seen one like it in a hotel and unlike other bed in a box type you can’t just return it . But , it is reasonably comfortable

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
Jun 9, 2025
JS
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible customer service on a terrible mattress!

Bought this mattress in September 2024. By April, the mattress was sagging and uncomfortable. Tried to return, but was strung along until I gave up on returning. Do not buy this mattress!!! It will feel good for a few months, but it won’t go the distance. Wasting your money. Sam’s club really failed on quality and customer service! Won’t buy any big ticket items from them again.

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
reply from Member's Mark Team

We are very sorry for the issue you have experienced with your mattress and the return process, JS. We'd like to assist you further, please contact Member Support at (888) 301-0332 and give them a chance to make this right for you.

Jun 4, 2022
AloisSchm
1 out of 5 stars review

Medium firm?! You are sinking into a sea of foam!

It starts with the unpacking. You will have to unwind layer upon layer upon layer of plastic - just great for the environment. First time I sat at the edge of the mattress I completely sank into it and my legs disappeared in the foam - I am only weighing 170 lb, mind you! Then I tried sitting at the top of the mattress, a large foam cushion behind my back, making me sit up straight for reading - I looked at my feet up in the air, because once again my buttocks sank into this supposedly medium firm sea of foam. I know I am supposed to sleep on this thing, but even stretching out on this soft foam you have to watch out not to suffocate because once again you are going under! the description says only the first layer is soft, well this thing is soft all the way to the bottom of it. Quite frankly, never have seen or laid upon such a piece of junk 'mattress' in my life, and I have slept on many. This thing is going back right away!

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
Mar 5, 2023
Suzanne Marie
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Nothing premier about it

Worst mattress I've ever had. Feel like I'm going to fall out of bed every night. If Sam's club didn't screw up my order the first time I have a great mattress. But they didn't render that situation the right way. So I got stuck with this one. It was horrible online customer service. When you're in a house fire all you want to do is sleep in a bed after 2 months of not having one. I waited for the one I ordered only for to be the wrong size sent. And then waited another two weeks for it to be refunded. And had to buy this one in a pinch. And it's awful completely awful. It's uncomfortable, I feel like I'm going to roll out of it and I feel sweaty and smelly from the mattress when I get up.

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819
reply from Member's Mark

We are sorry to learn about your experience, Suzanne Marie. Please contact Member Support at (888) 301-0332 and we'll do our best to make this right for you.

Dec 31, 2025
Jennifer
2 out of 5 stars review

Worked in a jam. Picked up a mattress on the cheap after ours was ripped my movers. I also picked up 2 twin xl for 2 of my kids after they got new beds. I shoukd have known better for our adult bed. It was comfortable for a little over a year, then had noticeable dips and sag in the top layer. My partner and I both weigh between 140-150, so we aren't overly large people. Rotating the mattress didn't help prevent the sag. After 1.5 years my back couldn't take it anymore, and this mattress had to go. I'm also noticing a bit of sag in the 8 year old's mattress. She's under 100lbs AND doesn't live with us/sleep here full time. The top layer just doesn't hold up. No issues on the mattress for the 4yr old but... she's 4. Same thing there - that she doesn't sleep over at our place every night. Wishing I had just gotten innerspring mattresses for the kids, and gone back to our original mattress (Tuft and Needle) from the get go.

Helpful?2P0LE98T4IU013891763819