Landscape fabric disintegrates. It used to be stronger. Now it is made of that shopping bag non woven type fabric that shreds and the weeds are growing right through it. It is difficult to pry up the metal pins to replace the only pieces left of it. Do not buy this.

I have been using this product for years but never again. For the past two seasons it has started falling apart half way through the summer. I used to use it on pathways and it would last a couple of years but no more. Once it starts to fall apart it becomes very difficult to get it up and out of the way. I will never buy this product again.

Bought a roll of this and used it on 2 flowerbeds against the house. Put in a bunch of plants and watered them. 2 hours later I still have puddles as if the water is not getting through the fabric. Going to be interesting when it rains tonight. If I wanted waterproof I'd just use Glad bags....I really, really, better not have to redo this project.

Two years ago this product was thick and did not disintegrate. It lasted two years in my garden but this year after only 50 days down in my garden the weed barrier is crumbling and weeds are pushing through. I'm so disappointed in this weed barrier this year.

No longer a contractor grade product. They changed it. I have bought this exact product before and was thrilled with it but they changed the manufacturer, clearly. The old one was heavy duty and did not rip. Landscape pins would not rip through. You could walk on it for a whole season, pull it up at the end of the season, and save it for the next year. NO LONGER THE CASE!!! The new version sold as the same product you can tear with your hands... unlike the old version. The new version is stretchy and twigs poke through. The new version will rip and pull of the landscape pins (I use different ones than the ones supplied because those are not good quality). The former version was so much superior and WAS contractor grade. The version they have this year is NOT THE SAME PRODUCT even though it is labeled the same. I want the manufacturer information for their old supplier so I can get the good stuff that used to be sold as this product. This is NOT contractor grade. You cannot walk on it when you put it between rows of plants without it ripping. You cannot take it up and reuse it year after year. I wanted to upload a video showing the difference between the old version and the new, both sold as the same product. How you can rip right through the new version easily and not the old one, but there is no way to upload a video. A picture would not show it at all... me trying to tear the old version and then how easy it is to tear the current version of this product. They got cheap and need to go back to the former manufacturer of this exact product. Or tell us who makes it so we can go by the product they used to sell under this name. That is the product that I want to buy, and they used to sell it, but they got cheap and now sell a cheap product as "contractor grade landscape fabric." It is NOT anymore. It used to be. Now it is just the same cheap landscape fabric you can get anywhere that rips and pulls apart and leaves shredded pieces in your garden!!!

Sams Club must have changed their vendor on this fabric! It used to be AWESOME and now it is CRAP!!! It tears after a month of use. I have have purchased and used this fabric for YEARS and it has been the best stuff ever. Last year it was terrible and tore to pieces. This year it is the same thing. I am going to return it. I would LOVE someone from Sam's Club to read this and FIX IT!!! Go back to the other vendor. I think we would all pay a few dollars more to not have crap!!!

Disappointed with both the product and customer service I purchased this weed barrier on May 2nd 2026 and laid it down under a layer of pea gravel in our backyard, hoping for a clean, low-maintenance look. It has only been two weeks, and I am already seeing numerous weeds pushing right through the fabric. It completely failed at its basic job. To make matters worse, when I went to the store to address this, the customer service team told me that in order to get a refund, I have to shovel up all of the pea gravel, remove the entire barrier, and bring the dirty, ruined material back to the store. Expecting a customer to undo hours of heavy labor just to return a defective product is absolutely insane. Very disappointed with the terrible quality of this product and the completely unrealistic response from customer service. Save your time, money, and back—buy something else.

It’s missing the stakes it’s supposed to come with

Best landscape fabric on the market

Weak fabric, weeds are able to grow through it.