Best Ice Cream

Used to love this ice cream, but they definitely changed the formula recently. It does not taste the same at all. It used to be a nice, rich vanilla ice cream. Now the taste is similar to McDonalds soft serve... very upsetting. Will not purchase again.

We enjoyed the ice cream that was in the blue bucket so much more than this new recipe. This new recipe has 14 g of added sugars per serving compared to 9 g for the recipe on the blue bucket. High fructose sugar is the 3rd ingredient of the new whereas the blue bucket’s recipe had high fructose sugar as the 6th ingredient. Buttermilk was the 3rd ingredient in the recipe on the blue bucket. The increased syrup and no buttermilk may account for the added sweetness.

This new ice cream is not as good as the ice cream in the blue and white pail. I am hoping that Sam's Club will listen and bring back the other ice cream. It is not as creamy. Thank you for your consideration. Through the years I have purchased so much of that ice cream in the blue and White pail.

I was surprised that this Member's Mark ice cream was such poor quality. The ice cream had tiny ice crystals throughout the entire container. My guess was the ice crystals formed because of low cream content in the product. This is one Member's Mark product that I will not purchase again.

Not as good as old brand

Good flavor and good value!

Poor taste and consistency

Too soft, decent vanilla flavor, good price for a gallon

I love to keep a tub in the freezer for my grandchildren.