I've had wild turkeys that weren't has tough as this one. Wow. Will only buy Butterball in the future

Turkey cooked perfectly in an oven bag. However it tasted awful. Tough and gamey tasting. Never again. Butterball next time.

I bought 2 of these seasoned as usual and baked as instructed. They were both tough and didn’t have any flavor. I would not recommend.

Where to start it stinks, dry, doesn't hold any of the flavor. It has to be one of the toughest piece of meats I have ever had. I would rate it 0 stars if I could!

Great bird. Roasted in a bag, came out great. What is funny is all the people here saying"get a Butter Ball", these are Butter Balls. Research and see.😄

Pulled out of yhe oven and presentation looks wonderful however trying to carve into it presented a problem..there is no meat on this turkey! I keep trying to upload pictures however Sam's Club app won't let me!

Every year we brine our turkey for 24 hours and then smoke it. This was the first year we purchased and used a members mark turkey. The turkey was tough and not near as moist as we usually end up with. I would definitely not recommend this brand.

I usually get a Butterball turkey and I wish I wouldn’t have wavered. We thought we cooked it wrong, but according to every review, it’s the turkey! It was tough and had no flavor. The star of the party failed us! 🙁

I won't be buying a turkey at Sam's anymore. Super dry and lacking any good flavor. I think this is the worst turkey I've made and it wasn't in error of my cooking.

good stayed moist