This used to be a weekly staple in my house in one of the reasons why I kept my membership, but to be honest they have changed something about this recipe and it's like a fluffy weird texture and there's also something orange that's been added, and the taste is completely different. Whatever they added, did not improve the salad.

the deli chicken salad used to be really good. the last two times I've purchased it it looked divverent- AND tastes like there is something wrong with it. I've wasted over $26 now, bc I was naive enough to think it was a single issue. are all the Sam's clubs in town using this new terrible tasting recipe? I'll refrain from ordering for pickup but rather go into the other clubs to see if they at least look like the consistency of the former recipe.

What have you done to my Rotisserie Chicken Salad? I have loved this chicken salad for YEARS! The seasoning has changed, texture is different and you've added ingredients. I don't know if it's to save costs but the quality has went down the tubes. PLEASE PLEASE CHANGE IT BACK!!!

I rarely write reviews, but I feel so strongly about this item I just had to add myself to the list of other upset customers… If it was possible to give it negative stars, I would… js This item has been a staple %26 a near constant FAVORITE at my home for many years… anytime a new person tried it at my home, they frequently ended up joining Sam's just for the awesome chicken salad, it was just pretty simple : rotisserie chicken chunks, celery mayonnaise, maybe onion powder or actual onions, maybe a little salt and pepper or something, but it was DIVINE !!! Whomever changed it made a TERRIBLE decision, sometime around May 2026 I believe, is when it changed. I literally returned it to the store because it was so terrible. I knew it looked different but was willing to give it a chance, took one bite and drove it back to the store for a refund … Reminds me of cat food or something the way it looks, and it doesn't taste much better than what I imagine wet cat food tastes like… The kind lady who processed my return was not surprised AT ALL, she said many many folks were returning it because it's just plain horrible now, so so sad :*( PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD RECIPE !!!!!!!

This has been a warm weather “go to” item for us in warm weather. Bought it for the first time this summer %26 was extreme disappointed. Normally there are chunks of chicken but this time it was almost all filler. What little chicken in it was very “stringy”. There was also too much garlic. Hopefully, this was just a bad batch but I will hesitate to spend my $ on another one

Absolutely garbage now. There's no rotisserie flavor, it tastes like canned chicken, and it's basically mush. Also, I like pickles as much as the next guy but the taste is overwhelming here. We won't be buying this anymore. Sam's Club, don't make me start going to BJs.

The rotisserie chicken salad used to be so good, loaded with flavor and big chunks of chicken. It was a favorite for years. They have changed the recipe, and unfortunately it is not good. I would not purchase it again. Please consider bringing back the old recipe.

why was the recipe changed? It's just mush now with too much mayo. a lot of the flavor was the chunks of chicken. I thought maybe it was only the whse I usually shopped at, but I just bought one yesterday at another location, and it's the same mush, so disappointing.

They must've changed the recipe. This chicken salad is horrible!! The old recipe was delicious... this is barely edible. We won't be buying this anymore. Sam's, you should be ashamed to sell this and shame on you for changing it into something this bad.

This has been my favorite chicken salad for years, and I have recommended it over and over. I picked up the new recipe this morning, and it was very disappointing. The chicken and the whole mixture was completely pulverized, rather than the previous chunks and pieces of vegetables, and the recipe is much sweeter than it was before.