Italian Creme cake is my absolute favorite cake, but it’s extremely labor-intensive to make so I decided to try this one (and you can’t beat the price). The cake itself is decent, but it had a strong extract flavor to it (seemed like orange, or some citrus flavor). It wasn't like a typical Italian Creme cake that would be homemade so unfortunately I wouldn’t buy it again.

While this flavor of cake is one of my favorites, this cake is so sweet we couldn't eat it. I don't know if Sam's cakes are normally this sweet or something happened to this batch, but a bowl of sugar isn't this sweet. I would recommend staying away from this cake.

This a beautiful cake. It's decorated beautifully and looks fancy enough for special occasions. At first bite, it's mind-blowing; the cake is moist, frosting is sweet and creamy. This cake would be a solid 5 stars, but I had to leave off a star because after a few bites, the cake becomes too sweet. If you eat an entire slice be prepared for the sugar rush and eventual sugar crash.

I had to order my cake. When I picked it up 3 days later (the scheduled date and time) the sale by date was the next day. The cake was actually made the day I ordered it. The frosting was split and sliding off the top. I would have refused it but it was purchased for a party that I was on my way to the day I picked it up.

I purchased this for our family game night and everyone that tried it agreed it was the best tasting cake. The icing was not overly sweet, there was just enough coconut, the icing wasn't too thick…you could eat all of the icing or leave it on your plate. Worth the money!

This Italian Crème Cake is absolutely delicious and always a must have when it's offered at Sam's Club over the holidays. Everyone always asks where it was bought and are stunned when I tell them it's from Sam's. Highly recommend and always a hit in our household.

Such a beautiful cake. Unfortunately that was all that was good about it. Cake was dry, no flavor. Frosting so thick with no flavor. Absolutely not an Italian cream cake. Had I not taken it to a dinner out of town I would have returned it. Nobody ate their piece and the all was tossed. Waste of $20.00

This was so delicious. Would buy again.

To sweet. Back off in the sugar some it would taste better.

I was expecting some lighter cream filling.