While this flavor of cake is one of my favorites, this cake is so sweet we couldn't eat it. I don't know if Sam's cakes are normally this sweet or something happened to this batch, but a bowl of sugar isn't this sweet. I would recommend staying away from this cake.

Cake was decent, toasted coconut was good, the icing was sugar mixed with syrup, mixed “I-don’t-know-what” that made it sickeningly sweet and almost unpalatable. Recommended by bakery employee in place of sold-out pumpkin pies. Would not recommend this “cake”!

This a beautiful cake. It's decorated beautifully and looks fancy enough for special occasions. At first bite, it's mind-blowing; the cake is moist, frosting is sweet and creamy. This cake would be a solid 5 stars, but I had to leave off a star because after a few bites, the cake becomes too sweet. If you eat an entire slice be prepared for the sugar rush and eventual sugar crash.

Italian Creme cake is my absolute favorite cake, but it’s extremely labor-intensive to make so I decided to try this one (and you can’t beat the price). The cake itself is decent, but it had a strong extract flavor to it (seemed like orange, or some citrus flavor). It wasn't like a typical Italian Creme cake that would be homemade so unfortunately I wouldn’t buy it again.

The cake was fresh, it looked great, and most importantly it was delicious.

Everybody loved this cake. It was so good.

To sweet. Back off in the sugar some it would taste better.

This was so delicious. Would buy again.

This was the best cake I’ve ever had outside of a restaurant or bakery. Delicious!

So fresh, tastes like a high quality luxury cake