My daughter-in-law’s birthday is December 25th. This was the perfect birthday dinner/Christmas cake. A little large and hard to cut but otherwise perfect.

2nd one in 2 months, great combo however the wrapping makes it very difficult to cut slices out. It is a GIANT CUPCAKE, paper is ten times thicker and you can’t cut thru the paper.

This cake is amazing! Flat out delicious from the first bite to the last. It's another incredible Sam's baked good that isn't good for my diet. That mean yummy!!

Yes, it is as amazing as it looks. It's a full-size cake - not just a cupcake. Treat yourself and family. All of the Carlo's Bakery items are delicious.

The cake didn’t have any flavor aside from it just falling apart crumbling because it couldn’t hold its shape. The filling was super sweet as well as the icing on top. So sweet even the kids didn’t like it because it would make your teeth hurt.

Great party cake! Chocolate cake, thick peanut butter filling and center column, rich, fudgy frosting on top. Remove from base for best cutting experience but still expect to make a big mess. But it was delicious!

We enjoyed this cake, it was very moist and delicious, but it’s super rich! A small slice is all you need. The chocolate is very good and the peanut butter filling is really nice too! I would recommend it and purchase it again.

We were pretty disappointed with this. Lacked in flavor and was a mess to cut into. We each had a slice and it sat in the fridge until trash day. Just bring back the big chocolate cake year round please.

Too dry!!

What a hot mess! First, almost all the sprinkles were placed on the paper, not the cake. Second, removing the paper was difficult and made such a mess, especially with those sprinkles that went all over the place! Third, every time you cut into it, the slice pretty much crumbles. Lastly, it is so dry! Quite a disappointment.... in both Sam's and Carlo's.