The cake didn’t have any flavor aside from it just falling apart crumbling because it couldn’t hold its shape. The filling was super sweet as well as the icing on top. So sweet even the kids didn’t like it because it would make your teeth hurt.

It looked great and who doesn’t love peanut butter and chocolate. In reality the cake seemed dry and we just couldn’t cut it into good slices with all the textures even after chilling it . It just kinda crumbled

What a great decadent dessert! I love all the peanut butter flavor. The cake was so moist and was perfect for my family event! Run to your nearest Sam's club! Hopefully they're on the shelf for a long time. Love Carlo's Bakery!!

Cake was difficult to unbox. Crumbled even after following directions to let it set at room temperature for a few hours prior. Messy. Underwhelmed. Disappointing. Will not purchase again. Will let others know of poor experience.

I don't normally leave food reviews. Im aware there are all types of tastes. This cake/cupcake was terrible. Dry and poor flavor of cake. The peanut butter moose they called it was very mediocre at best. There was nothing redeeming about this. Absolutely not worth the calories. Im throwing the rest away right now. Anyone who is a baker or accustomed to quality sweets will haye this cake. Maybe if you only compare against other store cakes its okay, but i dont even see how. The 2.5 stars or whatever this has right now, is too generous in my opinion.

Not worth rhe money.

This cake feeds a crowd and then some it is HUGE! Aside from a slight boxed-cake taste (not enough to knock off a star), it really is good. The peanut butter mousse is tasty--not overly cloying. Nice and light. The cake itself is super moist and stays moist for well over a week. We kept it in its original container in the fridge. The fudge frosting is delicious--very ganache like. Confession: we didn't read the instructions to let it sit for a couple of hours before serving and we loved it. I'm sure it's even better when the directions are followed.

Too dry!!

Would never buy again. The cake is a pain to cut because of the stupid paper surrounding it. Why is the frosting/sprinkles on top of the paper. Very dumb. The cake is dry, it falls apart as you cut it. It's basically the biggest waste of 20 bucks I've spent in quite sometime. Sams should stop selling this disaster immediately.

Talk about regret. This looks beautiful but that's all it has going for it. It has a cardboard cupcake wrapper thats a pain to get off. Cutting it was a nightmare. And quite honestly, it just doesn't taste very good. Even my 5 year old wouldn't eat it.