One of the only store bought carrot cakes I actually like. It's fresh and not dry unlike most store bought cakes.

Cake itself was good, no nuts except a few sprinkled on the top and the frosting is awful. It is a fake whipped topping, not cream cheese.

Cake is dry and stale tasting despite having a good date. Would not reccommnd buying it. The frosting doesn't help despite there being a lot of it.

This 3 Tier Carrot Cake was the "ALL TIME BEST" that My Husband and I have had since Leaving Mi., when we Could Purchase a 7 Layer Carrot Cake from a Resturant! We eat the Whole Cake between the 2 of us in 2 Days!

I've had far better at Chuck-a-Rama, a buffet restaurant.

This cake is very good. Whenever we want carrot cake I buy this one.

It's the best carrot cake with just perfect cream cheese icing, money worth.

I'm calling this, foul. There are a few great things at Sam's that I truly love-- one is their carrot cake. NOT this bar cake, but rather their beautiful double (or triple?) layer carrot cake. Bring it back, please.

Cream cheese frosting is not too sweet . We like it. Just enough spice so it’s not overwhelming. Cake is moist. Tastes like comfort food to me. I personally like a lot more walnuts than what was on the icing.

Sam's club makes the best carrot cake. Anyone complaining here must not appreciate a carrot cake in general. My only wish is that they bring back the double layer carrot cake with all the carrots decorating the top!!!