I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. The flavor was okay and would have benefitted from more pumpkin that would have added some needed moistness. The size was very generous and too big for a smaller family. My husband took over half of it to share with coworkers. Probably will not buy this same product again unless it gets an upgrade.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. The first piece I had I didn't love it. This isn't for thanksgiving or to fill that pumpkin spice craving. It came in a pie tin and I think somewhere that made me think pumpkin pie so when it was really and truly a pumpkin inspired crumb cake my mouth and mind were confused. However, the crumb has a hint of apple and the cake is very slightly pumpkin and pairs wonderfully with coffee for a special treat that would suit a fall brunch beautifully.

PLEASE bring back the NY Style Crumb Cake! This pumpkin-flavored thing is bigger and heavier, but it's nowhere near as delicious as the NY Style was. The amount of pumpkin-flavored foods and snacks is really ridiculous and out of control. We don't need everything to taste like pumpkin. Who is buying all this stuff?

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. This cake was very moist and flavorful, however, I like pumpkin and would have liked a stronger pumpkin flavor. The crumb topping was good but a bit on the hard side and fell off the cake easily. A more moist crumb would make it more delicious. The size was perfect for sharing with a large crowd. The price was great for this size of cake. I would buy it again and would definitely recommend this dessert.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. I am definitely a pumpkin spice girly and this cake did not disappoint, as a matter of fact it was down right amazing warm with some ice cream! The flavors of fall were perfectly balanced and the crumble on top was the perfect quantity and texture. The only thing that I would have liked better is if the cake itself hadn't been quite as crumbly right out of the dish, it definitely improved with a quick zap in the microwave and even better with a scoop of vanilla. The size and value of the cake was unbeatable and my friends were delighted to share!

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. The product quality wasn't as I had hoped it would be in comparison with other Member's Mark bakery products. The streusel topping was very hard, difficult to cut into and almost impossible to bite into. Perhaps something happened to it during transport or display. Apart from that, the flavor of the cake was excellent with a subtle pumpkin flavor and spices appropriate for this style of crumb cake.

Tasted stale and overcooked

Bad

Very dry

Yuck tasteless and very greasy