Very disappointed with this pumpkin crumb cake. The cake was about an inch tall and the crumb varied in height based on the location, but in some cases it was more crumb than cake. It came off a bit bland and dry. Would not buy again.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. My husband and I did not like this cake at all. We felt it was dry with very little flavor. The crumbles were not buttery or delicious. My kids liked it ok enough to eat almost all of it.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. The flavor was okay and would have benefitted from more pumpkin that would have added some needed moistness. The size was very generous and too big for a smaller family. My husband took over half of it to share with coworkers. Probably will not buy this same product again unless it gets an upgrade.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. This cake was very moist and flavorful, however, I like pumpkin and would have liked a stronger pumpkin flavor. The crumb topping was good but a bit on the hard side and fell off the cake easily. A more moist crumb would make it more delicious. The size was perfect for sharing with a large crowd. The price was great for this size of cake. I would buy it again and would definitely recommend this dessert.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. The cake itself was very moist and delicious. However, I found the crumb part to be very dry and there was way too much of it. The majority of it fell off as I was trying to eat it. Overall, I enjoyed it.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. The first piece I had I didn't love it. This isn't for thanksgiving or to fill that pumpkin spice craving. It came in a pie tin and I think somewhere that made me think pumpkin pie so when it was really and truly a pumpkin inspired crumb cake my mouth and mind were confused. However, the crumb has a hint of apple and the cake is very slightly pumpkin and pairs wonderfully with coffee for a special treat that would suit a fall brunch beautifully.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. To start, I have always used Members Mark desserts for any celebrations we have, and was really excited to try this Pumpkin Crumb Cake! Unfortunately, it was not at all what I expected. The presentation was very inviting, however the flavor was extremely lacking. I think they forgot to put in the aromatic spices, because there was no flavor at all. The buttery crumb topping was hard, but it did have a sifting of powdered sugar. It was very dense, and was not moist at all. I did check the processed date and best if used by date, and they were both fine. Extremely disappointing, and not up to Members Mark standards that I am used to.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. First the pumpkin crumb cake looked and smelled very tasty. With the fall just beginning I was excited to try my first taste of pumpkin for the season. The cake sliced easily enough but the crumb topping did not. It was hard at the edges and fell apart when trying to remove a piece. The cake was very tasty and had the right amount of spice but was dry. The topping was not good. It was extremely dry and pretty tasteless. I would not recommend this cake.

This Pumpkin Crumb Cake was purchased 9/24/2024 and shared at a potluck that evening where everyone {who likes pumpkin) raved about how very tasty the cake was. The cake did live up to its name and was rather crumbly but still served very well in slices.

I received a reimbursement for this product to leave an honest review. I am definitely a pumpkin spice girly and this cake did not disappoint, as a matter of fact it was down right amazing warm with some ice cream! The flavors of fall were perfectly balanced and the crumble on top was the perfect quantity and texture. The only thing that I would have liked better is if the cake itself hadn't been quite as crumbly right out of the dish, it definitely improved with a quick zap in the microwave and even better with a scoop of vanilla. The size and value of the cake was unbeatable and my friends were delighted to share!