I tried these protein shakes before the “new recipe.” I liked them but they were a bit on the thicker side. The new recipe has a smoother texture, similar to Premier Protein brand. The flavor is great and does not leave any type of chalky residue or aftertaste. I enjoy the Member’s Mark and it’s always great to save a couple bucks over the brand name!

The amount of protein in the shake is great, but you can taste the bad quality ingredients. It’s good for someone who just wants the most protein possible but for everyone else, it’s probably better to go with muscle milk for the same price and just cut the 5g of protein. At least you’ll be able to drink it without gagging.

I tried this after drinking premier protein for a couple of months. I thought it might taste fine. I was wrong. The taste is not good at all. I do not recommend this to anyone if you like to drink a protein drink you don't have to force yourself to drink because of the terrible taste.

I have been buying premier protein chocolate shakes for years, and I really love using them as the creamer in my coffee. I thought I would try the member's Mark brand since they were cheaper, but they are terrible! They have that very chemical sweet taste and I wound up just dumping out the whole cup of coffee. I'm going back to the premier protein.

Protein shakes are not my go to for a meal, but sometimes you just don't have time for anything else. That being said, these are your average protein shake. There is an aftertaste, but they do taste pretty good at first, and have a lot of protein, which is good. There are better tasting brands out there, but the price is good for these.

Tried several different brands and this one is definitely in my top two. Satisfies my love of chocolate while giving me the extra protein I need. Great for pre or post workouts. Keeps me from overeating and helps me stay full longer. If you are looking for a great tasting protein shake at a fantastic price this is for you.

I enjoy the taste of these protein drinks. This is one that does not spike my blood sugar which is very important to me as others are low carb but spike my blood sugar. These are great for on the go or to take to work. I highly recommend this product.

I live a busy life and tend to skip meals way too often. These shakes are great for an on the go meal replacement or pre workout drink. With 30g of protein, one shake is very satisfying and 1g of sugar fits well into my low carb diet. The chocolate flavor tastes great especially after putting in the freezer for 30 minutes. The price is more affordable than other name brand high protein shakes I've tried and these are the same or better quality.

For some reason Fairlife has been hard to find, premier protein hard to find and limited flavors when they do have any in stock. I took a chance on these hoping they were as good but I just can't. Barely got through one and now I have this huge box sitting here. I can't even give them away.

I usually purchase Premier Protein shakes, but Sam's fooled me with their Members Mark knockoff. I didn't catch it until I drank the first shake. I knew immediately that I messed up. The Members Mark shakes flavor profile is off and has a distinctively unpleasant aftertaste. You will not fool me again.