Tried a case of these after comparing the ingredients to Premier, which it's obviously supposed to imitate. The ingredients and nutrition are pretty much identical, but the taste is not. Chalky and sickeningly sweet with artificial sweetener aftertaste. How could you screw these up so badly Sams? Throw them out and go back to the drawing board!

This Members Mark Protein Shake is excellent, it tastes great, it’s packaged conveniently; and one can take the product anywhere, especially to the Gym for a nice refreshing beverage after workout. These Member’s Mark High Protein Shakes are available in a delicious creamy chocolate flavor. Each shake contains 30 grams of protein, 25 vitamins and minerals per serving, 160 calories, 1 gram of sugar, and 2 grams net carbs. These shakes provide an excellent source of iron, calcium, and vitamin D which helps you build strong bones and muscles. I also noticed that it helps with my post-workout recovery process. I love the shakes and I highly recommend them.

Tastes good and very similar to more expensive products with the same ingredients. Have used it a few days so far as a snack instead of chips and it fills me up, avoiding extra snacks throughout the day. I recommend this product and plan to try additional flavors when available.

I ordered these because the delicious Fairlife protein shakes were out of stock. This is the worst Member’s Mark product I’ve ever tried. I’ve choked down two and think I’m probably going to throw the rest of the case away. They are awful. Horrendous. Sam’s needs to go back to the drawing board with this product.

I do intermittent fasting. I take them to work and place them in my office fridge. When I feel hungry this is the perfect drink (substitute meal). Make sure that they are really cold. Close to frozen is perfect. Does not taste chalky. Does not leave an aftertaste. Only 160 cal and 2pm carbs minus the fiber.

Shake is very thick

Taste good to me. Of course, it does have a different chocolate taste than Premier brand but I like Members Mark brand chocolate as well & it comes with 3 more shakes than Premier so that’s a plus. It’s thick but not too thick for my taste. I enjoy it. Does what I needs it to.

This shake had a good flavor and texture without a chalky taste. It was a little too sweet for my taste or I would have given it a 5. My daughter-in-law drinks protein shakes regularly so I asked her to try it, too, and she said it tasted as good as the name brand shakes that are much more expensive. It's also very convenient. A medicine I take requires me to wait 30 minutes after taking before eating, and this is great to take on the road when I need to leave extra early.

Very, very good protein shake product. Happily surprised at the smooth, creamy texture of these shakes. The flavor is outstanding with zero, troublesome "after-taste" so common among diet products. This is equivalent to the popular DYMATIZE brands of protein products. Will definitely purchase in the future. Thanks Sam's Club!!

Even after removing the lid the product would not come out except in a slow drip. I thought the product was bad so I threw it away. The second one was the same way so I stuck a knife in the side because I was going to cut the carton in to. That was when I realized there was a clear plastic film over the hole and you have to stick something into the opening to cut the plastic then you have to be concerned that part of it may have fell into the drink