I’ve tried a lot of shakes, and these are one of my favorites, especially for the price. I like the thickness, if you chill them and shake occasionally, it’s a good consistency. The ingredients are nutritious and it doesn’t cause problems with my gut issues.

Short version: Solid product, good flavor and texture, and seems to have improved from earlier formulas. I'd recommend trying it for yourself! Long version: I have tried many brands of both ready-to-drink and powdered protein shakes and meal replacements. As a certified chocoholic, I LOVE chocolate. However, chocolate is often my least-favorite flavor in protein products. I have had some genuinely BAD experiences with chocolate flavors; it just seems like manufacturers struggle to get the flavor and texture right while keeping sugar content and calories low. I often opt for vanilla or other lighter flavors and have settled on Premier Protein as my favorite chocolate-flavored protein drink. Always looking to save a dollar or two, I purchased this product within the last year as a lower-price alternative to Premier Protein. Frankly, I hated it. The chocolate flavor was very light, almost chemical-tasting, and the consistency was gaggingly thick and chalky. I said I'd never buy it again because the lower cost was not worth suffering through consuming the lower quality product. Enter the MyMembersMark program and free samples. While I was NOT excited to hear I was getting samples of a product I did not like, I did my part and tried it. After doing so, I have to say either my first experience was a 'bad batch' or they have improved upon the formula since I purchased the product. The flavor is a richer chocolate with none of the slightly chemical 'off' taste I noted in the case I had purchased. The consistently is pleasingly thick, without being chalky or cloying. The result of my latest tasting: I would buy it again and recommend trying it for yourself. While admittedly still not quite on par with Premier Protein, this is a suitable alternative for value conscious consumers of ready-to-drink protein products. My question for Sam's and Member's Mark: when are you coming out with additional flavors??

I like the protein content and the consistency makes it easy to drink, plus this is the best price for similar protein drinks sold in stores. Only downside is the aftertaste (not as tasty as other brands) but it’s something you’ll get used to, especially for this price point.

The reviews are all over the place on this shake. I’m new these protein shakes but I’m only using with the purpose to curb my hunger during the day to lose some weight. The nutritional value seems to be on par with other shakes and it doesn’t taste that terrible. I just need something with good value and keeps me from hitting the drive through, it does that just fine. Chocolate flavor is okay, thickness is okay (it’s a SHAKE so yeah it’s supposed to have some thickness), value is good and performance is great. If you’re on the fence, just give it a try. Just don’t buy 4 boxes of the stuff if you’re not sure. If you’re looking for something that taste like liquid snickers that you can dunk your cookies in then you may want something else.

These are gross. I drink lots of protein drinks and these are disgusting. I think the other 5,000 reviewers have broken taste buds. These have to be chugged and then chased with water just to not waste them. On second thought, i will now go brush my teeth to get the aftertaste out of my mouth.

18 Shakes for $24.98 in Honolulu as of 7/28/22 - can't beat the price! Yes 3 more shakes for the same price as Premier. I do think Premier tastes just a tad better however I can sacrifice a little taste for the price since when I drink protein shakes since I use them as a post workout shake, where I won't savor every sip. The main issue with protein shakes for me is it has 30 grams of Protein like Premier.

I normally purchase Fairlife chocolate protein shakes! I was purchasing to make Ninja Creami ice cream and decided to get these, because they were cheaper. My family thinks these are disgusting and I agree… chalky and just off. We’ve thrown out any of he ice cream made with Member’s Mark and are trying to give away the rest of the shakes. It reminds me of what my chocolate lip gloss tasted like when I was a kid… not good. Buy the Fairlife or even Muscle Milk.

I drink a protein shake every single morning. When Sam's Club came out with these last year I tried them. I didn't like them at all & noticed that they removed them from the shelves a few months later. I noticed these shakes were back, so I wanted to try them again since they probably changed the formula. I am so glad I gave them a second chance! These taste very similar to the name brand! I was very excited about that since I do drink at least one of these a day. I am excited to save some money on these! I will definitely be purchasing these in the future.

I decided to try the Member's Mark protein shakes instead of the national brand to save some money, and they tasted great. They shipped to our house quickly and my whole family started drinking them for breakfast and after they work out. 18 won't last us long.

I love taking this to work with me. I have found that it works nicely for lunch. It tastes great and helps me get through the day. I especially like the chocolate. It has just the right amount of chocolate. I seem to have more energy to deal with a classroom full of students after I have one of these protein shakes. I will definitely be buying more.