Is it me or is the price going up? It is not even cheaper than the competitive brands out there. Why make a store brand product and mark it at the same price?

The taste is chocolaty but very chalky as well, also the consistency is very thick. The only way I can have them is blending them with a banana and PB2 powder. I will not buy again.

I will never buy these again unless they change their formula and I can taste test them in store. They taste terrible. Premier Protein is much better.

I hoped I'd like these as well as the premier drinks, but they are a bit chalky and I don't love the flavor nearly as well. Maybe as I work my way through the box, I'll come to like them more.

These only okay. Lacking in the chocolate flavor of the Premier Protein shakes. Will not buy again. Mixing with the Premier Protein Peanut Butter flavor. I hate to waste foods, so I will use and not return. But may donate to food pantry too.

I will stick with Premier Protein brand when possible. These are gritty. Not extremely but enough that you can feel it when you put your teeth together.

It is drinkable but has a really weak chocolate flavor. Also gave me... ahem... some flatulence that the name brands don't. I'll finish them off but won't buy again. For comparison's sake Atkins dark chocolate is my favorite.

With Premier Protein shakes also available, makes no sense to use these poor tasting shakes. Saving only $.20 per shake is just not worth it. This chocolate has that bad “sifted through a dirty sneaker” aftertaste. Will make your skin crawl.

Don't waste your money. The taste is off and has a sweet and almost nauseating taste and aftertaste to it. Buy atkins or premiere. I regret this purchase and will likely just end up throwing them out.

I currently drink Atkins shakes and bought these hoping they would be comparable but they are awful. The flavor was fine but the consistency was yuck. Super chalky and like sandy like you could feel the protein powder in your mouth.