I asked for one layer to be chocolate and the other vanilla, they were both vanilla. The cake was crooked but I didn't mind that. But there was a HAIR in our cake. That's what got to me. The cake itself was good as always.

I had Sam's make me a plain cake and I decorated it

I ordered a plain cake for my baby shower and it was uneven. It was very noticeable but luckily we were able to salvage and hide the unevenness the day of. The cake itself tasted good and it was moist.

used this as my wedding cake, sooooo many great compliments on the taste. our wedding colors were very minimal, black and white- I had the cake topper ordered on shein for 10 bucks. and this was SUCH a great decision.

Ordered a simple white 2 tier cake from picture off the website for my daughter’s wedding. Picture showed no piping & should have been cake on cake. Frosting was all pockmarked & had 2 thick pieces of cardboard & plastic in between the layers. I told the guy it was awful. He said I can put icing as trim to cover the ugly center boards. I said they shouldn’t be there. He said cake would collapse. I said my daughter didn’t want piping & it should look like picture. I used to decorate cakes. Told him the cake wouldn’t collapse. I also said she doesn’t want piping, but if he could give me extra frosting I could maybe smooth out the poorly done existing frosting job. He said he couldn’t give me frosting…but he could pipe it. Again, daughter did not want piping. Wedding was next morning so we were stuck with an awful cake. About a half hour before guests arrived at her reception next day. She & I were literally reconstructing the cake. Absolutely ridiculous! Since I had done cakes before, I helped her remove the ugly pieces of cardboard & plastic that were showing. Put additional buttercream, that I had made, on to the cake & we did a scrape method to remove the pockmarks. Took some of her faux flowers from her decorations & added to the cake….all while guests were showing up. Would not recommend Sam’s Cub for cake. Such a bad experience!

The cake was delicious, but it wasn't decorated the best. I have decorated cakes in the past and could have done a better job than this. It passed but the cake was not level, and the icing was not smooth. Because Sam's Club corporate removed options of special icing and decoration, we could not even get white roses on a white cake. They only offered bright red, blue, and yellow. Think circus colors. We could only get a dot or shell border. I was not offered other options in store when ordering, and later discovered some alternate designs that might have worked online. The staff was not helpful except for one lady who took the time to help us because all the options had changed from 1 month prior when we had picked out the options for the cake and cupcakes. Then we got to order and find they changed all the options and limited them to just a few. We had to look in the case to try to figure out what sprinkles and decorations on cakes or cupcakes were what. They no longer have many options of colored sprinkles or icing colors. It was pretty disapointing. They are doing the same thing as their competitor C...Co is too. They now have even less options. Despite not being able to get what we wanted, the prices for cakes and cupcakes are far less than what it would cost elsewhere.

Please whatever you do go somewhere else ! I know some cakes come out good and some bad here but don’t take the chances it’s the most disappointing thing ever. I ordered for my wedding simple plain as can be cake just two layer white cake that’s all i asked for . It was a bit lopsided but the kicker was they left a FREAKING cardboard piece right in the smacking middle of the cake and didn’t cover it. They could have covered it so easily but they left it out and about. I was so upset that my husband and i had to do a secret cake cutting just cause of how embarrassed i was of everyone seeing that. Never ever ever will i order anything from this bakery again.

I ordered a plain white icing cake with white trim for a wedding shower. I had decorations for the cake that matched the theme. I ordered the top layer chocolate and the bottom layer white. I don't think I have received so many great reviews from guests about a cake in... forever. Everyone raved. Thank you Sam's for being a hit!

This my forever cake this is the best for me the best design and the best flavor vanilla cake