These vary in what you get. Sometimes they are full of gristle and other times they are delicious and tender. I'm sticking to Ribeye from now on.

Everything‘s too hard today, but it stinks of blast. This was a very good steak even though it was a pain Trista it was a Cut Above.

absolutely worst cut of New York strips I've ever had. every bite was tough and filled with connective tissues.

Tasty steaks. I only buy my steaks at Sam’s. Things are getting more expansive but Sam’s price is the best I could find.

I bought a Charcoal grill for the lake and purchased these steaks, oh my heaven.... amazing! I want steak every night now!!

The steak was very tough and hard to chew. We are going to use the remainder of the steaks for dog food.

Grilling Time - steaks were great, the right thickness and tender. I hope they’re from the Southeast USA.

I have bought this twice recently and both times it was tough and sinewy. Could barely chew it. Won’t be buying again.

I bought some in January 2026 and they were tender, flavorful and great quality. Returned in February 2026 and they were rubbery, tough, filled with gristle not marbling, and flavorless. Really disappointing for the costa and won't buy them again.

for some reason there is always one steak that I wouldn't feed my dog BUT the other 3 or 4 are most vary good beef.. Don't know why the store always includes one steak that is not worthy of dog food