Good

very tough

Lots of gristle.

Even though, there is always a smaller 4th steak in every package(Great, as a back-up, or next day steak, to go with leftover veggies). These steak's are always great on the grill. The char even taste's great! Now, I have had mid-western beef in the past, and that's exactly what this tastes like to me. And, the mid-western steak's I am referring to, were butchered from the cow, literally about an hour before we paid for them, in Kansas. And, I always use my own rub on them, before I vacuum seal them in the vacuum sealed bag's, so they can marinade overnight. From my experience with these steak's, it has always been a great experience. And, my family has been buying steak's from our local Sam's Club, for decade's. And, we have never been disappointed, in all aspect's, as far as I can remember...

I cooked one steak to a perfect medium and then wore out my jaw trying to eat it. The meat was tough, chewy with too much connective tissue for "choice". I spit out much of it because I could not masticate it enough to swallow. I returned the remaining steaks to the store, I was grateful to get my money back.

These are great. I absolutely love them, but I noticed sometimes there is one or two steaks in the pack that aren't quite New York strip-like. I'm sure they are technically strips, but the marbling and flavor are just not the same. It happens more at one store than the other one I go to, so... Not sure what that means, I just make sure to look closely before I buy now.

We have been buying these for years. The steaks looked like they would be good, but they were the toughest steaks I have ever had in my babyboomer life! We couldn't eat them. Literally. We have another 2 in the freezer and my husband said maybe we could dice them and simmer in chili. I hope this is not another cutback. They wouldn't have passed as select grade...so disappointing.

The original Steak online was price $54.99. When i went to pick the Steaks up i check the price on the label. They was label $25. But i was charged $49. I was suppose to get for times the amout because Sams over charged for Steak. But they refunded the difference. if i would have pulled off after they loaded my car before checking i wouldve never knew that i was over charged.

Flavorful

They were great