Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Nordic Ware Extra Large Oven Crisping Baking Tray for
Nordic Ware Extra Large Oven Crisping Baking Tray
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars
548 ratings202 reviews
  1. 5 stars86% (473)
  2. 4 stars7% (41)
  3. 3 stars2% (13)
  4. 2 stars1% (8)
  5. 1 star2% (13)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 61-70 of 202 reviews
Dec 4, 2024
Sammyshopper
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great pan. Will get heavy use!

Larger than many pans that claim that they hold a lot. Easy to clean. A nice find.

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
May 1, 2022
zenkitty
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great pan!

Nice large pan for family size meals

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
May 23, 2022
Derek
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great tray for wings

Works great air frying wings in the oven

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
Nov 27, 2024
Tammy
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

I love this pan

I love this was roaster pan! I use it to spatchcock my turkey every Thanksgiving. I had borrowed my sons the last few years but I ended up buying my own this year.

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
Jul 2, 2026
MARIANNA
5 out of 5 stars review

Great pan... versatile, durable and easy to clean!

i purchased this pan several years ago from Sam's and I absolutely love it! It bakes beautifully, with and without the rack, it washes easily and has proven to be very durable. I highly recommend this product!

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
Jan 6, 2026
SONYA
1 out of 5 stars review

Really disappointed

I bought this with hopes of getting big batches of food done at once but the pan rusted only after weekly use of 2 months. I have no idea what's the obsession with making an inferior product. I mean obviously the corporations don't want their products to last forever because theirs no money in that but a product should at least last 2 years.

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
reply from Nordic Ware Customer Support

Hello, I am so sorry to hear of the difficulty. Please reach out directly to the Customer Experience team at Nordic Ware for assistance - info@nordicware.com. Kind Regards, Nordic Ware Customer Experience Team

Mar 22, 2026
JOHNNY
5 out of 5 stars review

It's Jumbo Size! Extra large!

This is a very large pan that takes up the entire oven rack but it fits inside my Frigidaire oven. I thought I was ordering the smaller size so imagine my surprise when I opened the package and saw how jumbo sized this pan was! Thankfully, it fits inside my standard home oven. I use these racks for baking bacon or for meal prepping 2 pounds of boneless skinless chicken thighs. The rack can go in the top rack if the dishwasher but the pan is hand wash only. I heavily line with foil the tray for easier clean up. I recommend everybody does that. I'll hand wash the rack but always place it in the dishwasher yo get it extra clean. I really like this jumbo pan. I'm glad Sam's Club offers it.

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
Jun 15, 2023
MD7
5 out of 5 stars review

Worked Better Than My Air Fryer!!

I took a chance and bought this to cook my large family onion rings on. I have tried the air fryer, regular baking in oven and they still were soggy. I bought this and my family went wild. I've made onion rings, breaded chicken and veggies, eggplant for my eggplant parm and more! We don't fry in oil anymore and I no longer am using my air fryer. For quick cleanup, I even put parchment paper under the rack so all the breadcrumbs were easy to clean up as they did stick without it. (The pan came clean with a little dawn and elbow grease when I forgot the parchment paper and there was no staining to the metal). The oven is repeatedly set to 450 Degrees when I cook in my electric oven and this performs fine. We have found this to be successful and I am currently buying a second one right now to make my eggplant parm go a little faster - lol. I highly suggest this purchase. Thank you for reading and God bless.

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
Nov 23, 2021
BB3
1 out of 5 stars review

My review about incorrect product info was deleted

Product is advertised on this webpage to be safe to 450F degrees; however, after purchase, I found that the product label (and the Nordic Ware website) state that the maximum safe temperature is 400F. (see attached photo) I previously submitted an unfavorable review and photo documentation of this error, and my review was deleted. Even more disappointingly, as of the time of this submission, the product webpage continues to incorrectly advertise the maximum safe cooking temperature to be 50 degrees greater than what is shown on the product label. Since the intended application is oven-roasting, this error results in a significant difference in the usability of this product because many recipes (such as oven-roasted potatoes) require 425F-450F for this type of cooking.

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640
reply from Supplier Response

Hello, The nonstick on the rack is actually oven safe to 450F, which has been verified with the coatings manufacturer. Because of the variation in oven temperatures in consumer homes, which can be as much as 50 degrees over what the temperature is set to on the control panel if the oven is not calibrated, we elect to label the packaging with a safety buffer built in. That way, if a consumer does have a hot spot in their oven or uses the product directly above or below the oven’s heat source, there is margin for error and the coating is protected...._.... We hope you can understand the reason for this labeling, and we apologize for the two different oven-safe temperatures being shown online vs. on the packaging. We have corrected the temperature online to match the packaging, but wanted you to be aware that the coating is rated to 450F...._....If you have additional questions, feel free to reach out to Nordic Ware customer service via email at info@nordicware.com or Phone: 1-877-466-7342..._...Kind regards, Nordic Ware

Jun 30, 2024
Alabamian
4 out of 5 stars review

Love it

Bought it in club several years ago and have used it for all my meat cooking needs simulating grilling or crisping. It is my number one go-to pan. Now one thing I've learned over the years, grease the rack like you would on a regular grill! Reason: the Teflon coating has started to peel in places which makes me hesitant and cautious in continuing to use it. The meat sticks to the rack without greasing, as expected. But how bad it sticks and how easy it is to clean are dependent on whether you grease it or not. That's where the coating peels off in cleaning afterwards, even with the most cautious cleaning method, soak in hot water until everything is soft and loose, use a non-scratch Teflon safe scrubber. I would love it if there is a separate rack that I can buy to replace it and not have to buy a whole replacement set. For those 2 reasons, I gave this 4 stars.

Helpful?5XBJA8O5IZ3713602764640