Tasted mostly of sour cream/mayonnaise. Not edible for any of us 4 who tried it. Wish I would have sampled it in the club first cause I would not have bought it.

DISGUSTING, it was like eating a half gallon of sour cream with lumps of potatoes and cheese in it.Went right in the trash

I wouldn't considered this a potato salad but more of a ranch soup with potatoes and toppings. Very disappointing.

This is quite possibly the BEST potato salad I've ever eaten!!! So much flavor in every bite. I'm not a huge fan of potato salad, but after this one 👍👍

TERRIBLE!. I returned a second container. When I told service member. she gave me back $ for both containers and said " I agree" its got too much sour cream.

Doesn't taste like a loaded potato. Doesn't taste like potato salad. Too much mayo/sour cream drowns out all other ingredients. Could use more potato, cheese, %26 salt and pepper.

We received this as psrt of a hostess gift. This is only good for folks that generally eat what is considered over processed and over seasoned food. The mayo/sour cream blend taste like the worst version of them and the cheddar cheese flavor is dominant and overly processed tasting. I cannot even recall the bacon flavor due to how bad the bad cheddar dominates. Sorry! Went into serving this expecting this to not come close to homemade. The five of us at home have different food criteria and all of us said toss it! Unless we received a bad one...

Absolutely awful and disgusting! The texture and taste are both unpleasant. I wish I could be more descriptive but it's truly something you have to experience. I tried several spoonfuls and the taste kept getting worse. I tried adding a little salt, then pepper, then a spoonful with a bite of chicken. This tastes so bad I'm actually angry that I consumed it. I've never asked for a refund on products I've disliked but this time I feel like I'm owed one. This goes beyond like/dislike, this is is not edible!

I had high hopes for this loaded potato salad, but it somehow missed it's mark for this member. The first thing that hit me was the overbearing hit of salt, artificial bacon flavor, mayo and a strange or almost slimy mouth feel from the sauce. I typically find myself wanting to eat the entire container of most potato salads. After 3 or 4 bites I quickly grew tired of it. I really like the loaded baked potato salad from Walmart and thought this one would be similar or even better. They aren't even close. On the plus side...The sliced potatoes were cooked perfectly, not mushy and not under cooked. Need to tone down the mayo taste/texture, reduce the salt and possibly add some acidity to it to balance out the flavors a bit.

When we tried the sample in the store, it was very good, so we decided to purchase. When we had more than just a small sample cup at home, it was super rich and hard to eat. Great for bringing to a gathering and sharing, but too much for just 2 people.